20 ausgewählte Italian Restaurants in St. Louis nach Empfehlung

Trattoria Toscana serves traditional Italian cuisine in a comfortable, welcoming setting. Guests highlight well-prepared dishes such as chicken specialties, veal entrées, and risotto, along with fresh salads and warm, crusty bread. Service is attentive and accommodating, with staff frequently tailoring preparations to individual preferences and pacing meals thoughtfully.

Dominic's Trattoria offers traditional Italian cuisine in a lively, welcoming setting in downtown Clayton. The menu features classic preparations of veal, lamb, pasta, and chicken, along with a simple, well-regarded house salad. Attentive, professional service and the option of private rooms make it suitable for both intimate meals and larger gatherings.

Gioia's Deli on The Hill since 1918 is a classic neighborhood spot specializing in hearty Italian-style sandwiches. The signature hot salami and the Italian combo are frequently praised for their bold flavors. Guests order at the counter, where staff guide choices with attentive, helpful service. Limited indoor seating and a few outdoor tables add to the casual, local charm.

Rigazzi's is a long-standing Italian restaurant on The Hill known for hearty comfort dishes and a casual, family-friendly setting. The extensive menu features familiar favorites such as pasta, pizza, chicken dishes, toasted ravioli, and substantial sandwiches. A separate gluten-free menu, including warm bread for dipping, offers many options for diners with dietary needs. The signature oversized beer schooner adds to the lively, convivial atmosphere.

Lorenzo's Trattoria offers classic Italian cooking in a comfortable, well-appointed setting on The Hill. Guests note well-executed pasta, seafood, and meat dishes, such as veal piccata and calves’ liver, along with traditional desserts like cannoli and tiramisu. Attentive service and the option of a private dining room contribute to a polished yet relaxed dining experience.

Charlie Gitto's On the Hill serves classic Italian cuisine in a polished, traditional setting. Guests highlight rich pasta dishes, seafood specials, and hearty veal preparations, prepared with attention to flavor and texture. Professional, accommodating service and a business-casual ambiance create a comfortable yet refined dining experience.

Trattoria Marcella offers classic Italian cooking in a quaint, candle-lit dining room that recalls traditional neighborhood trattorias. Guests highlight house specialties such as hearty lasagna and freshly prepared toasted ravioli, along with seasonal salads and pastas. Attentive, welcoming service and a well-chosen selection of wines by the glass contribute to an enjoyable, unhurried meal.

Bar Italia offers traditional Italian cuisine, from fresh cured meats and house pastas to comforting classics like chicken alfredo and tortellini. Guests can dine on the patio or by large front windows that overlook a chic, energetic neighborhood. Attentive staff support both intimate meals and private events in dedicated spaces such as the Luna Room, creating a polished yet relaxed experience.

Failoni's Restaurant offers a lively, neighborhood setting with a mix of Italian-inspired dishes, including seafood pasta and thin-crust pizza noted for its fresh ingredients. Attentive staff and an engaged kitchen team contribute to the welcoming feel. On some evenings, live music and singing by the team create a festive atmosphere.

Sauce on the Side specializes in generously filled calzones served with red sauce on the side, complemented by large, shareable salads. Guests highlight the flavorful combinations, from classic meat fillings to more creative options, as well as fresh, well-seasoned greens. The space is kept clean, and the staff provide attentive, friendly service even during busy periods.

Brio Italian Grille offers Tuscan-inspired Italian cuisine in an elegant, spacious setting. Guests highlight well-prepared dishes such as tender steaks, flavorful salmon, rich ravioli, and classic soups and salads, along with fresh bread. Attentive, efficient service and appealing presentation make it a fitting choice for both everyday meals and business or celebratory gatherings.

Little Fox offers a focused menu of inventive small plates designed for sharing, with dishes that highlight seasonal produce and bold flavors. The bar features distinctive cocktails and an intriguing wine list, including lesser-seen styles. Attentive staff guide guests through the menu, accommodating dietary needs and helping curate a balanced, communal dining experience.

Pizza-A-Go-Go is a longtime South Side Saint Louis spot dedicated solely to pizza, known for its crisp, flavorful crust and consistent quality. The compact, no-frills space is kept very clean, with a welcoming team taking orders at the counter. With limited seating and a simple setup, it caters especially well to carryout while focusing on its classic New York–style pies.

Pietro's is a family-owned restaurant offering classic Italian fare alongside familiar American favorites such as steak and thin, St. Louis–style pizza. Guests note crisp, well-prepared appetizers, a popular house salad dressing, and fresh Italian bread. The atmosphere is welcoming and comfortable, complemented by attentive, personable service.

This neighborhood spot specializes in hearty sandwiches, from classic Italian beef and cheesesteaks to meatball and Reuben favorites. Freshly prepared ingredients and soft, flavorful bread stand out, along with sides like fried Parmesan potatoes. The casual, low-key setting and efficient, welcoming staff create a comfortable place for a satisfying meal.

Eleven Eleven Mississippi offers contemporary American cuisine with Mediterranean influences, featuring dishes like wild boar ravioli, carefully grilled filets, and seasonal specials. The converted warehouse-style space feels warm and inviting, with a comfortable bar and intimate dining room. Attentive, knowledgeable service and a well-regarded wine and beer selection round out the experience.

Urzi's is a classic Italian market on The Hill, known for its wide selection of spices, pastas, olive oils, and housemade sausages. Shelves are stocked with prepared items such as ravioli, sauces, pesto, cannoli filling, and gelato for at-home meals. Attentive, welcoming staff contribute to the shop’s longstanding neighborhood appeal.

Favazza's on the Hill offers traditional Italian cooking in a classic neighborhood setting. Guests highlight flavorful pasta dishes, thin-crust pizza, and satisfying gluten-free options, including Margherita pizza. Attentive, accommodating service and a casual, comfortable dining room make it a welcoming choice for both everyday meals and special occasions.

A'mis Pizza offers a mix of New York- and Chicago-style pizzas, with crusts and toppings that earn frequent praise. Guests highlight specialties such as the eggplant pizza and the distinctive house salad dressing, often enjoyed with warm rolls. The setting is modest and can get busy, with staff described as polite and hardworking even during peak times.