The 20 Best Italian Restaurants in Bayside, Victoria

Vivace offers a fine dining experience with an extensive menu featuring Italian-inspired dishes, including handmade pastas and seafood. Guests highlight well-executed plates such as gnocchetti with lamb ragu, seafood linguini, and snapper. A thoughtfully curated wine list, attentive service, and warm, inviting décor create a comfortable setting for leisurely meals.

Cucina & Co is an authentic Italian restaurant in Brighton known for its well-crafted pizzas and classic pastas. Guests appreciate specialties like the ricotta calzone, complemented by a thoughtful selection of Italian wines and house-baked sourdough. The cozy dining room blends a lively buzz with relaxed comfort, supported by attentive, accommodating service.

Aromi Restaurant offers contemporary Italian cuisine with refined flavors and thoughtful presentation, from inventive small bites to delicately prepared pasta. Dishes such as soft shell crab and creative stuzzichini highlight the kitchen’s playful side. A lively yet comfortable dining room, attentive service, and a dedicated cocktail bar with a well-chosen wine list complete the experience.

La Cucina Beaumaris serves classic Italian cuisine, from risotto and slow-cooked ragu to seafood pasta, wood-fired-style pizza, and traditional minestrone. Guests highlight the well-prepared desserts and quality coffee alongside an extensive wine selection. A light-filled dining room, courtyard seating, and attentive, friendly service create an inviting setting for relaxed Italian meals.

Martinellas Brighton-Bay Pizza & Pasta is a local Italian restaurant known for its freshly made pizzas with generous toppings and flavorful combinations. Diners highlight both traditional and gluten-free bases, noting consistently good quality and taste. Quick, friendly service and convenient takeaway options make it a popular choice for relaxed Italian dining.

Black Olive on Black Rock offers Italian favorites centered on wood-fired pizzas, including well-regarded gluten-free options with carefully chosen toppings. Guests highlight generous shared plates such as calamari and carpaccio, Italian wine by the glass, and considerate service that accommodates dietary needs, all in a welcoming setting with a fire in cooler months.

Da Belcibo serves classic Italian cuisine in a compact, comfortable setting. Wood-fired pizzas with thin, crisp bases and fresh toppings are a highlight, alongside housemade pastas, lasagna, and traditional starters. Guests often note the attentive, welcoming service that adds to the inviting neighborhood feel of the restaurant.

Napolitano Pizza specializes in flavorful, well-balanced pizzas with a light, crunchy crust and generous toppings. Diners note the quality ingredients, from vegetable-focused combinations to seafood options with juicy prawns, alongside hearty pasta dishes and garlic bread. The team is known for attentive, considerate service, including careful accommodation of dietary needs, and the cozy space offers a few seats both indoors and outside.

Azzurro Pizza Pasta and Grill offers classic Italian comfort food with consistently well-prepared pizzas and pastas. Diners note generous portions and the kitchen’s willingness to accommodate preferences, from crust style to toppings. The atmosphere is relaxed and informal, with service that is efficient and reliable for both dine-in and takeaway.