The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Ontario

The Tangerine Tortoise is a small, casual neighborhood restaurant with an unassuming storefront that still carries its original appliance shop sign. Inside, an owner-chef prepares a frequently changing menu, with guests praising the thin-crust pizzas, pâtés, and sliders. Carefully sourced ingredients and personal, attentive service create a relaxed setting for a laid-back meal with thoughtfully prepared food.

East Side Mario's offers hearty Italian-American favorites in a lively, welcoming setting. Guests highlight comforting pasta dishes such as chicken parmigiana and ravioli, complemented by generous bread, soup, and salad. Attentive, personable service and a clean, well-kept dining room contribute to an enjoyable, relaxed meal.

Romano's Restaurant offers classic Italian cuisine with an emphasis on authentic flavors and comforting dishes. Guests highlight well-prepared favorites such as grilled calamari, rigatoni with Bolognese, and veal with mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables. The atmosphere is described as comfortable and modern, while the staff are attentive and accommodating, even preparing off-menu requests.

Crust & Crate offers a casual setting for wood-fired pizzas, sharable appetizers, and craft beers on tap. Guests highlight the well-topped, nicely cooked pies and fresh salads. A shaded patio with cozy booths and indoor screens for sports create a relaxed, social atmosphere. Attentive staff and a clean, comfortable space make it appealing for both small groups and larger gatherings.

Bonfire on Queen offers comforting Italian-inspired dishes with an emphasis on freshly prepared pizza, pasta, and sandwiches. Thin-crust pizzas with generous toppings, hearty lasagna, and well-crafted specials like risotto or chicken sandwiches highlight the kitchen’s approach. Housemade desserts, including gelato and cannoli, provide a satisfying finish. Attentive, welcoming service and thoughtful takeout presentation round out the experience.

Boston Pizza offers a casual, brand-name dining experience with familiar, well-prepared dishes served hot. Guests note consistently welcoming hosts, quick seating, and clean tables. Attentive servers engage comfortably with groups and families, helping create an easygoing atmosphere for both small gatherings and larger parties.

Those Pizza Guys serves hand-pressed, wood-fired pizzas with thin, crisp crusts and generous toppings, with options like a Greek-inspired pie highlighted in reviews. The small indoor space and casual patio, which is noted as pet-friendly, create an easygoing stop in downtown St. Jacobs. Quick, attentive service and local craft beer selections round out the experience.

SaL'S Pizzeria serves hearty, topping-loaded pizzas with a crunchy, flavorful crust, alongside wings, subs, and other casual favorites. Signature options like taco pizza and gyros stand out in reviews for their bold flavors. Guests describe the dining room as clean and comfortable, with attentive, personable staff contributing to a welcoming local feel.

JR's Pizza is a casual pizzeria known for customizable pies with ample cheese, sauce, and toppings. Guests highlight the kitchen’s attention to special requests, from extra-thin crusts to sauce and toppings right to the edge. Service is described as attentive and accommodating, contributing to a satisfying, straightforward pizza experience.

Located in the CF Don Mills complex, The Good Son offers a modern bistro experience with a lively patio and a comfortable dining room. The menu features thin-crust pizzas, hearty plates such as steak frites and burgers, and thoughtful salads and desserts. Guests highlight well-balanced flavors and attentive, knowledgeable service at both brunch and dinner.

The Good Son offers a contemporary dining experience built around inventive cocktails and flavorful, well-prepared dishes. Guests highlight seafood starters, hearty mains like slow-cooked meats, and thoughtfully crafted pizzas. A well-decorated interior with multiple rooms creates an energetic yet comfortable setting, supported by attentive, efficient service.

Jack's Family Restaurant offers classic family-style dining with a broad menu of comfort dishes, from fish and chips to salads and wraps. Portions are generous and meals arrive hot, with desserts like lemon mousse or cake noted as a highlight. The atmosphere is lively, especially on busy evenings, and the staff maintain attentive, efficient service even when the dining room is full.

MJ's Gourmet Pizza is a family-run spot focused on classic, scratch-made pies, with dough and sauce prepared fresh each day. The counter-style space centers on takeout, with pizzas crafted to order and tailored to guests’ preferences. Friendly staff, quick turnaround, and consistently flavorful pizza define the experience.