The 20 Best Italian Restaurants in Toronto, Ontario

Enoteca Sociale is a Michelin Bib Gourmand restaurant offering refined Italian-inspired cuisine in a cozy, inviting setting. An ever-changing menu, available as a chef’s tasting experience, highlights seasonal ingredients in thoughtfully plated dishes, from grilled fish to rustic vegetable sides. Attentive staff, an engaging sommelier, and a well-curated wine list round out the relaxed yet polished dining experience.

Giulietta is a Michelin-selected restaurant offering contemporary Italian cooking with carefully prepared seafood, house-made pastas, and wood-fired specialties. Dishes like branzino, beef tartare, and cacio e pepe showcase bold yet balanced flavors. Attentive service and a lively dining room create an engaging experience.

ARDO Restaurant is a Michelin-selected restaurant offering Sicilian-inspired Italian cooking in a relaxed, unpretentious setting. House-made pastas, crisp flatbread-style pizzas, and distinctive Sicilian appetizers showcase focused, balanced flavors. Attentive, genuinely friendly service and thoughtful wine pairings complete the experience.

Don Alfonso 1890 is a Michelin one-star restaurant offering contemporary fine dining with sweeping views over Toronto and Lake Ontario. Multi-course menus showcase high-quality ingredients in precisely cooked, artfully presented dishes such as seared duck, tenderloin wrapped in Swiss chard, and seasonal fish. An extensive wine and cocktail list complements the cuisine, and attentive, detail-oriented service enhances the overall experience.

Capocaccia Trattoria offers classic Italian cooking with a creative touch, from artichoke appetizers and carpaccio to pizza, pasta, seafood, and grilled meats. Guests highlight consistently well-prepared dishes and an extensive wine list. A warmly lit patio and welcoming dining room create an inviting setting for relaxed meals with attentive, unhurried service.

East Side Mario's offers classic Italian-American comfort food, from hearty pastas and pizzas to popular soup, salad, and warm bread. Recently renovated, the dining room is bright, open, and comfortably furnished. Service is described as attentive and efficient, contributing to an easygoing, enjoyable meal.

Scaddabush Italian Kitchen & Bar Sherway serves contemporary Italian dishes in a casual, comfortable setting. Guests highlight flavorful pastas, such as butternut ravioli, and well-prepared meat and seafood options. Attentive, knowledgeable service and a lively atmosphere make it a popular choice for relaxed Italian dining.

Sofia Italian Restaurant Toronto offers contemporary Italian cooking in a stylish, high-energy setting with upbeat music and a fashionable crowd. Dishes such as black cod, roasted potatoes and house desserts are prepared with care and appreciated for their flavor. Attentive, knowledgeable staff, from the wine steward to the servers, contribute to a polished, leisurely dining experience.

Parcheggio offers Italian comfort dishes such as housemade pasta, hearty lasagna, and tender grilled calamari, prepared with attention to flavor and texture. Guests highlight the fresh appetizers, including focaccia and caprese, and classic desserts like tiramisu. A spacious dining room and responsive, accommodating staff contribute to a relaxed and enjoyable dining experience.

Levetto is a cozy Italian spot known for its pizza, pasta, and a selection of wines. Guests highlight flavorful pies, including a prosciutto and arugula option, as well as satisfying pasta dishes and desserts like coconut cake. The atmosphere features enjoyable music and a comfortable patio, with staff described as welcoming, though service can occasionally feel unhurried.

La Vecchia Restaurant Lakeshore serves classic Italian cuisine with an emphasis on fresh ingredients, from crisp thin-crust pizzas and housemade pastas to comforting soups and grilled seafood. Guests note attentive, efficient service and a well-run dining room. A stylish interior and a patio with views of the lake and downtown skyline create an appealing setting for leisurely meals.

Mercatto offers classic Italian cooking with well-executed pastas, crisp antipasti, and traditional desserts, complemented by a carefully selected wine list and quality espresso. The atmosphere is lively yet comfortable, drawing many guests from nearby offices and institutions. Guests can choose between indoor seating or a sidewalk table while attentive staff provide polished, personable service.

7 Numbers DANFORTH offers traditional Southern Italian cooking in a cozy, romantic setting. The family-run restaurant is known for hearty classics such as lasagna, seafood, and lamb dishes, along with comforting antipasti like sautéed mushrooms and mussels in tomato and white wine. Attentive, accommodating service and a welcoming atmosphere make it a popular spot for both intimate dinners and larger gatherings.

Grappa Restaurant offers classic Italian cooking with carefully prepared dishes such as housemade pastas, seafood starters, and traditional desserts. Guests note attentive service, including thoughtful wine presentation and a willingness to accommodate special requests. The ambiance is comfortable and inviting, with live music on some evenings and a calm atmosphere earlier in the night.

7 Numbers EGLINTON offers comforting, homestyle Italian cooking prepared in a compact open kitchen at the front of the room. Guests enjoy hearty classics such as veal lasagna, lamb shank, and eggplant parmigiana, along with generous salads and pastas. The atmosphere is relaxed and homey, with attentive staff and an inviting, communal feel.