The 20 Best Restaurants in Peoria, Arizona

Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant serves classic Italian favorites in generous portions well-suited to sharing, making it popular with families and groups. Guests highlight dishes such as lasagna, salads, garlic bread, and cannoli. Attentive, upbeat service and a quaint, festive atmosphere contribute to an enjoyable, social dining experience.

Firebirds Wood Fired Grill offers a lively setting for classic American steakhouse fare, featuring wood-grilled steaks, prime rib, and hearty sides like potatoes and salads. Guests describe the steaks as tender and well cooked, with flavorful accompaniments. The staff is accommodating and attentive, and the bustling dining room can become energetic and noisy, especially on busy evenings.

BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse offers a broad menu of American-style favorites, from hearty bowls to familiar comfort dishes, served hot and well-prepared. Guests highlight attentive, coordinated service, even for large groups. The atmosphere is energetic yet comfortable, making it suitable for a wide range of ages and tastes.

The Social on 83rd offers contemporary American comfort food, from burgers and sandwiches to pasta and salmon, along with inventive cocktails and dessert drinks. A compact, stylish space with an indoor-outdoor bar, patio seating, and games creates a lively social setting. Attentive staff provide helpful recommendations, contributing to an engaging dining experience in this busy Peoria neighborhood.

Fleming's Prime Steakhouse & Wine Bar offers a polished setting for leisurely dining, with guests noting an immaculate environment and thoughtful attention to detail. Steaks and classic steakhouse fare, including dishes like calamari, are praised for their quality and preparation. Knowledgeable staff guide diners through the menu and extensive wine list, providing attentive yet unhurried service.

Ah-So Sushi & Steak offers a lively teppanyaki experience with chefs who cook and entertain at the grill. Diners enjoy a range of dishes such as steak, seafood, teriyaki chicken, fried rice, and vegetables, noted for their appealing flavor. The spacious dining room and attentive service create a comfortable setting for groups and casual gatherings.

Serra Gaucha Brazilian Steakhouse offers a traditional rodizio experience, with servers bringing a wide selection of grilled meats directly to the table. Guests can complement their meal with a generous self-serve bar featuring salads, soups, rice, and hot dishes such as beef stroganoff. Attentive, courteous staff help create a smooth and enjoyable dining experience.

Famous Dave's Bar-B-Que serves classic American barbecue, featuring ribs, brisket, roasted chicken, and sandwiches complemented by sides like cornbread muffins, coleslaw, and baked potatoes. The restaurant often feels lively and bustling, with attentive staff checking in on guests. A dedicated take-out area with convenient parking makes pickup and catering orders straightforward and efficient.

P.F. Chang's offers a modern take on Chinese and Asian-inspired cuisine in an upscale, contemporary setting. Guests highlight flavorful classics such as hot and sour soup, sweet and sour chicken, and generous salads. Service is attentive and efficient, and many diners appreciate both the comfortable ambience and the convenient options for enjoying the food.

Ray’s Pizza serves classic, hearty pies known for their crisp crust, abundant cheese, and slightly greasy, flavorful finish. Sausage pizza with sliced sweet Italian sausage and a multi-topping specialty pie are frequently noted. Starters like mozzarella sticks and fresh salads round out the menu, making it a comfortable choice for a casual meal.

Ballpark Pizza & Subs offers classic American comfort food, from pizzas and subs to meaty jumbo wings, salads, and desserts. Fresh ingredients and generous portions are frequently noted, whether guests stop in for a quick slice or a full meal. Multiple TVs show sporting events, creating a lively, casual atmosphere. Attentive, welcoming service rounds out the relaxed, family-friendly experience.

Arizona Broadway Theatre combines a tiered, well-decorated dinner theater setting with live musical productions. Guests dine on composed entrées while enjoying shows noted for strong singing, clear diction, and engaging acting. Attentive, professional staff and thoughtfully designed sets help create an immersive evening of entertainment.

Mercer’s Restaurant is a long-standing neighborhood favorite known for hearty American comfort food and a broad, diner-style menu. Guests highlight satisfying classics such as chopped steak dinners, seafood plates, and homemade desserts like carrot cake. Efficient, friendly service and the ability to handle both everyday meals and larger groups contribute to its enduring appeal.

The Sicilian Butcher offers contemporary Italian cuisine with a strong focus on customizable meatballs, sauces, and pastas. Guests also find generous salads, antipasti, and classic starters like bruschetta and calamari, along with satisfying desserts. The atmosphere is modern and quirky yet welcoming, and attentive staff contribute to an overall enjoyable dining experience.

Hooked on Sushi is a family-owned Japanese restaurant known for fresh, carefully prepared sushi and sashimi. Diners highlight properly firm fish and attractive presentation, with bento boxes and substantial combination plates among the options. A broad menu offers alternatives to sushi, accommodating a range of tastes. Attentive service and a simple, comfortable dining room with background music create a relaxed experience.

Located inside a gas station, Casa De Falafel Restaurant - Mediterranean Grill serves authentic Mediterranean fare centered on freshly prepared falafel, shawarma, and salads. Guests highlight the crisp, donut-shaped falafel, flavorful tahini, and comforting lentil soup. Clearly marked vegan choices and attentive, welcoming staff contribute to a relaxed, family-run atmosphere.

Bubba's 33 is a lively sports bar–style restaurant offering hearty American comfort food in a clean, upbeat setting. Guests highlight flavorful burgers, wings, pizzas, and classic options like fish and chips, along with light, fluffy garlic knots. An extensive drink list, from cold draft beer to cocktails, complements the menu. Attentive, welcoming service and manager check-ins contribute to a consistently positive experience.