The 20 Best Restaurants in Arcata

Northtown Coffee is a laid-back café known for well-crafted espresso drinks, including lattes and chai, alongside satisfying breakfast options like burritos with fresh ingredients. Guests note the relaxed, slightly funky charm of the space, with art and games adding to the character. Attentive, helpful service and a comfortable atmosphere make it a pleasant place to start the day or take a break.

McIntosh Farm Country Store offers hearty, made-to-order breakfast dishes in a casual, country-style setting. Guests highlight the generously filled breakfast burritos, including a popular version with sausage gravy, as well as French toast with berry sauce. Portions are substantial, and the relaxed atmosphere encourages lingering over a leisurely morning meal.

Redwood Curtain Brewing Company is a lively taproom known for its thoughtfully crafted beers, from bright, fresh IPAs to barrel‑aged specialties and distinctive sours. A rotating selection keeps the lineup interesting, and the spacious setting, patio seating, and reliable Wi‑Fi make it comfortable for lingering. Guests often pair their drinks with offerings from visiting food trucks or their own food.

Cafe Mokka combines a relaxed coffeehouse with adjoining hot tubs and saunas for a distinctive, spa-like escape. Guests enjoy espresso drinks, teas, and a small selection of light fare in a rustic setting overlooking a pond and garden. A longstanding local favorite, it offers a calm atmosphere for unwinding after outdoor adventures or a busy day.

Wildflower Café and Bakery offers a fully vegan menu with satisfying comfort food that appeals to both plant-based and non-vegetarian diners. Guests highlight flavorful dishes such as noodle bowls in spicy satay sauce, nut burgers, and creative sandwiches. The small, nicely decorated dining room has a homey, convivial feel, and the attentive staff contribute to an inviting, relaxed experience.

Kebab Cafe offers casual Mediterranean fare with a focus on gyros, kebabs, and falafel. Diners highlight the flavorful sandwiches, including lamb kofta and chicken kebab, as well as fresh salads. The small dining room fosters an informal, neighborhood feel, while quick, attentive service and a strong takeout following add to its appeal. A selection of local beers complements the menu.

Located inside Hotel Arcata, Tomo | Japanese Restaurant offers sushi, sashimi, and classic Japanese dishes such as tempura and teriyaki in a casual, welcoming setting. Guests appreciate the quality of the seafood, the selection of sake and cocktails, and the attentive, efficient service.

Valley Azteca Restaurant offers authentic Mexican cuisine with generous portions and bold, satisfying flavors. Guests highlight the homemade chips and salsa, expertly prepared huaraches, and rich flan for dessert. The dining room feels warm and welcoming, with attentive, friendly service that adds to the experience, making this strip-mall spot a pleasant surprise once inside.

Hey Juan Burritos serves made-to-order burritos and fish tacos prepared with high-quality, locally sourced ingredients. Guests can customize their orders with various fillings, sauces, and salsas, including a popular creamy house sauce. The small, funky space has a laid-back vibe that can feel lively and close-knit when busy, complemented by a rotating selection of microbrews on tap.

Plaza Grill offers a welcoming setting with plenty of character, combining a quiet dining room with an inviting bar area. The menu features a broad range of American favorites, from seafood and comfort dishes to thoughtful vegetarian and gluten‑free options. Guests note well-prepared plates, balanced flavors, and attentive service, whether dining in small parties or larger gatherings upstairs.

Cafe Phoenix & SMOKED Backyard BBQ serves fresh, flavorful dishes ranging from hearty sandwiches and tacos to tofu scrambles and omelettes. Many guests note the wide selection of gluten-free options and housemade hot sauces. Courteous, efficient service and quick delivery of meals contribute to an easygoing experience. A leafy garden patio with artwork and outdoor seating offers a relaxed setting away from the bustle indoors.

Stars Hamburgers Arcata is a locally owned spot specializing in classic burgers, fries, and crisp onion rings made with fresh ingredients. Burgers are cooked to order, with options like crispy bacon and seasoned fries. The compact dining room has a casual, no-frills feel. Friendly staff and sociable guests contribute to its laid-back, neighborhood character.