The 20 Best Restaurants in Derby, Connecticut

Mattei's Deli And Catering offers homestyle Italian favorites, known for dishes like thin-sliced eggplant Parmesan, chicken Parmigiana, and chicken Marsala with rich, flavorful sauces. A ready-prepared section provides convenient take-home meals that still feel homemade. The deli also supplies generous entree trays suitable for gatherings and events.

Altimaris Little Italy is a classic Italian deli and small market known for its hearty sandwiches, including porchetta and traditional Italian combo grinders. The counter features authentic Italian meats and cheeses, alongside imported pasta and pantry staples. An adjoining area serves espresso and baked goods, while the welcoming, family-run atmosphere adds to its neighborhood appeal.

Roseland Apizza is a long-established pizzeria known for thin-crust pies with flavorful sauce and generous toppings. Guests describe a nostalgic, family-style atmosphere with attentive, hard-working staff. In addition to its signature pizzas, the menu includes hearty pasta dishes and distinctive salads that round out the Italian-American offerings.

THC The Hops Company offers a spacious beer hall with long communal tables and a wide selection of beers on tap from around the world. The self-service setup features bar snacks and pizza alongside the extensive drink list. Guests can relax indoors by the fireplace or head to the large outdoor deck with fire tables, a waterfall, and lawn games for a casual, social experience.

Apollo Pizza specializes in Greek-style pies with a crisp, well-cooked crust and generous toppings. Regulars highlight the consistency of the pizza, from house specials to veggie and meat options, along with popular wings, chicken parm dinners, and salads. Pleasant, personable service and daily specials contribute to its appeal for takeout and casual meals.

Italian Pavilion offers classic Italian-American favorites, from hearty pastas and pizzas to homemade soups and garlic rolls. Generous portions and familiar flavors define the menu, with options like seafood dishes and traditional spaghetti with sauce. The dining room features an open, casually old-school setting with high ceilings and film memorabilia. Attentive, experienced staff contribute to an easygoing, family-friendly atmosphere.

Valley Diner Restaurant serves generous portions of classic American diner fare, from substantial salads to hearty sandwiches and comforting grilled dishes. Guests highlight flavorful options like roast beef, steak sandwiches, and omelets, as well as rich brownies for dessert. The setting features roomy booths and counter seating, and service is described as friendly and efficient.

Housed in a historic former bank, Twisted Vine Restaurant offers hearty, flavorful food and generous desserts in a setting of vaults, nooks, and winding stairways. Guests mention standout gnocchi with meatballs and well-mixed cocktails. A downstairs lounge with live music, dancing, and courteous service gives the place a lively, playful energy.

Tipsy Tomato Bar & Pizzeria serves Italian-American favorites with a strong focus on thin-crust pizza praised for its flavor and texture. Guests find a spacious interior with a cozy dining room, comfortable booths, and a compact, energetic bar area. Dishes such as chicken parmesan and hearty soups complement the pizza offerings. Clean surroundings and attentive, personable service contribute to a consistently enjoyable experience.

Jersey Mike's Subs specializes in hot and cold sandwiches made with meats sliced to order and vegetables served on fresh rolls. The menu offers multiple sizes and a salad-style “Sub in a Tub” option for those skipping the bread. Grilled fillings are cooked on a flat-top, creating hearty, made-to-order subs. Simple indoor seating supports both quick dine-in and takeout meals.