The Best Restaurants in Cudjoe Key

Broil offers an intimate setting for polished steak and seafood dining in the Keys. Guests highlight well-prepared dishes such as filet mignon, pork chops, scallops, and fresh fish, along with rich, housemade desserts like carrot cake and cheesecake. Attentive, welcoming service and careful presentation create a relaxed yet refined experience.

Moritas serves hearty Cuban home-style cooking, from pressed sandwiches with roast meats to plates of grilled chicken with rice, black beans, and sweet plantains. Guests describe the food as simple, flavorful, and satisfying, complemented by cafe con leche. The modest, homelike setting and welcoming staff create a relaxed, lived-in atmosphere, occasionally accented by the presence of friendly resident animals.

The Bent Prop Bar & Grill offers a refined take on coastal dining, with carefully prepared seafood such as swordfish, scallops, and shrimp & grits. Guests dine in a stylish space with distinctive decor, a lively bar, and indoor-outdoor seating overlooking the water. Attentive staff offer thoughtful recommendations, while creative appetizers and polished presentations round out the experience.