The Best Italian Restaurants in Englewood, Florida

Geraldi's is a modest, counter-style pizzeria known for its thin-crust, New York–style pies with well-seasoned toppings served hot from the oven. Guests highlight the sausage pizza and generously portioned salads for their satisfying flavors. Friendly staff and a small outdoor seating area with umbrella-shaded tables create a low-key, tucked-away setting just off the street.

Mama's Italian Restaurant is a small neighborhood spot offering a broad menu of classic Italian dishes, from pizzas and pastas to hearty chicken specialties. House-made dressings, fresh salads, and grilled garlic bread are often noted, with many guests especially enjoying the pizza. Service is described as attentive and personable, contributing to a straightforward, unpretentious dining room experience.

Ricaltini's Bar and Grille offers a casual, welcoming setting where guests find a lively bar scene and frequent entertainment. The menu emphasizes familiar bar-and-grill favorites alongside seafood options such as calamari, lobster ravioli, and cedar-planked salmon. Attentive, personable service and consistently fresh dishes define the experience.

Englewood Billiards & Brew combines a well-kept, smoke-free pool hall with a casual bar and grill atmosphere. Multiple regulation and smaller tables provide plenty of space for games, while a full bar supports a lively social scene. The kitchen serves classic pub-style dishes, with guests frequently noting the quality of the pizza and generous portions. Attentive staff and a clean setting make it a comfortable spot to relax over food, drinks, and billiards.