The 20 Best Italian Restaurants in Jacksonville, Florida

Midtown Table offers creative, upscale Italian-inspired dishes in a casual, contemporary setting. Guests highlight flavorful house bread, pastas, seafood, and comforting desserts like bread pudding. A spacious covered patio with views of a small putting green adds a relaxed outdoor option, while attentive, professional service supports an unhurried dining experience.

Maggiano's Little Italy serves satisfying Italian-American favorites in a lively, well-organized dining room. Guests highlight dishes such as fried zucchini and eggplant parmesan, along with rich desserts like butter cake. Attentive, knowledgeable servers help guide choices and contribute to an enjoyable, relaxed meal.

BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse offers classic American comfort food alongside its own selection of beers. Guests mention a wide range of choices, from hearty sandwiches and chicken dishes to pasta favorites. Service is attentive and personable, with staff frequently checking in. The atmosphere suits both business lunches and relaxed gatherings with drinks.

Carrabba's Italian Grill offers a range of classic Italian-American dishes, from hearty pastas to grilled specialties, alongside salads, soups, and warm bread with seasoned oil. Guests highlight flavorful options such as spaghetti marinara with sausage, hearty pork chops, and comforting house soups. Fresh Italian and Caesar salads and a selection of desserts round out the meal. Service aims to accommodate both everyday diners and larger groups in a lively, relaxed setting.

Moon River Pizza serves hearty, generously topped pies, calzones, and salads in a lively neighborhood setting with classic rock playing in the background. The menu includes thoughtful options for different diets, including vegan pizzas with toppings like marinated tempeh and dairy-free cheese. Attentive, upbeat staff and a selection of beer and imported wine contribute to its easygoing, social atmosphere.

Prati Italia serves classic Italian cuisine with an emphasis on rich flavors and quality ingredients, offering options for gluten-free and vegetarian diners. Guests mention well-prepared pasta dishes, robust salads, and a thoughtful drink selection. The interior is described as inviting, with additional outdoor seating that enhances the overall dining experience. Attentive staff and responsive management contribute to a smooth visit.

Newk's Eatery offers a broad menu of sandwiches and comfort-style sides in a clean, inviting dining room. Guests note consistently fresh, well-prepared food, from signature sandwiches like the Newk’s “Q” to classic macaroni and cheese and slaw. Orders are prepared quickly, and the attentive, accommodating staff contribute to an easygoing, pleasant meal.

Rustic 21 Bistro offers Brazilian-inspired bistro fare in a stylish, tastefully decorated dining room that feels like a hidden find inside a simple shopping center. Guests highlight skillfully prepared dishes such as cod croquettes, pork milanesa, fresh salads, and house juices. Coffee is presented in a distinctive table-side service that adds to the experience. Warm, attentive staff and comfortable acoustics create an appealing setting for relaxed meals.

Mellow Mushroom Jacksonville - River City offers a lively, family-friendly setting for enjoying pizzas with crisp crusts and fresh toppings, along with shareable appetizers like pretzel bites. Guests note the broad beer selection and well-made cocktails. Staff are described as attentive and accommodating, including for special dietary needs and larger groups, creating an easygoing, social dining experience.

Carmines Pie House serves generous portions of pizza and Italian-American comfort food in a lively, welcoming setting. Guests highlight both the Chicago-style and New York-style pizzas, along with rich pasta dishes such as Alfredo. Attentive, personable service and a loyal base of regulars contribute to its inviting neighborhood feel.

Blaze Pizza offers a build-your-own, wood-fired pizza experience where guests watch their pies assembled along an open preparation line. Thin-crust pizzas come out quickly with fresh toppings, flavorful sauce, and notable mozzarella. Options such as cauliflower crust appeal to those seeking lighter alternatives. The spacious, clean dining area and efficient, helpful staff contribute to an easygoing meal.

Pizza Point is a casual neighborhood pizzeria known for its thin-crust pies, from classic pepperoni and hearty meat combinations to an Indian-inspired chicken tikka masala option. Guests also find baked pasta dishes, eggplant parmesan, and calzones prepared fresh and served hot. The welcoming staff and comfortable, laid-back setting create an easygoing spot for everyday meals.

Catullo's Italian is a small, cozy restaurant offering classic Italian cuisine in an intimate setting. Guests highlight well-prepared dishes, from appetizers through dessert, with balanced flavors and satisfying portions. A full bar complements the menu, and the staff is noted for attentive, knowledgeable service that enhances the overall dining experience.

Mellow Mushroom Jacksonville - Town Center serves hearty, soft-crust pizzas with a wide selection of toppings and specialty combinations, including gluten-free options prepared with care. Guests can choose from several distinct dining areas, a lively bar, or the outdoor patio. The atmosphere is casual and eclectic, and the staff is known for being accommodating and attentive.

Taverna offers a spacious, modern setting with minimal decor and a relaxed, contemporary feel. The menu leans Mediterranean and Italian, featuring composed salads, housemade pastas, and seafood and meat dishes like short rib and scallops. Craft cocktails, including bold espresso martinis, and a thoughtfully chosen wine list complement the food. Attentive, enthusiastic service contributes to a polished yet comfortable dining experience.

Leci’s Italian offers classic Italian dishes in a comfortable, neighborhood setting. Guests note a satisfying lunch buffet with salads, pizzas, pastas, chicken, and vegetables, as well as generously portioned entrées like veal in lemon sauce and spaghetti with meat sauce. Fresh salads, crisp-crusted pizza, and traditional desserts such as cannoli round out the experience.

Blaze Pizza offers a fast-casual, build-your-own pizza experience where guests choose their sauce, cheeses, and a wide range of fresh toppings. Pizzas are assembled to order along a counter and baked in a high-heat brick oven. Staff guide newcomers through the process and accommodate requests for extra toppings or a crisper bake, creating a personalized and efficient meal.

Carrabba's Italian Grill offers Italian-inspired cooking alongside hearty grilled specialties in a lively neighborhood setting. Guests highlight consistently well-prepared dishes, from tender steaks to braised beef short ribs, complemented by fresh salads and sautéed vegetables. Attentive, coordinated service contributes to a smooth and welcoming dining experience.