The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Orlando, Florida

BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse offers a broad American-style menu alongside a varied selection of beers, wines, and other drinks. Guests describe a relaxed, laid-back atmosphere with attentive bar and table service. Generous portions and comforting dishes, from hearty mains to indulgent desserts, make it a popular choice for casual dining and drinks.

Lazy Moon Pizza is known for its oversized slices featuring a sweet red sauce and a crisp, dippable crust. Guests appreciate the inventive flavor combinations, such as Cuban-inspired options and house specialty slices. The atmosphere is lively and casual, with a busy dining room and a dog-friendly patio. Attentive staff help keep service smooth even during peak times.

Pizza Xtreme serves classic, crowd-pleasing pizzas with a well-baked, crispy crust and balanced toppings. Guests highlight fresh salads, flavorful wings, and consistently satisfying personal and large pies. Service is described as attentive and accommodating, with efficient delivery and a straightforward, casual setting that focuses on the food.

Flippers Pizzeria serves classic, freshly baked pizzas with a focus on rich flavor and satisfying textures. Soft, buttery breadsticks are a standout favorite, complemented by warm cookies for a sweet finish. Guests highlight consistently accommodating service, whether dining in or ordering for delivery, creating a dependable, casual spot for pizza cravings.

Blaze Pizza specializes in build-your-own pizzas, allowing guests to choose their dough and a wide range of toppings before the pies are quickly baked to order. Diners note the thin, flavorful crust and the option for thoughtfully handled gluten-free pizzas, along with fresh salads. House-made flavored lemonades add a refreshing complement to the meal.

Flippers Pizzeria specializes in hand-tossed pizzas made with noticeable attention to sauce, cheese, and toppings. Guests praise the flavorful combinations, including options with pesto bases and plentiful vegetables as well as hearty meat selections. The atmosphere is straightforward and informal, with efficient, accommodating staff and a convenient setup for both dine-in and takeaway.

NYPD Pizza Lake Cay serves New York–style pies with a well-liked crisp yet chewy crust and a balanced, not overly spicy sauce. Guests also mention flavorful chicken wings, garlic knots, and cheesecake. The dining room handles steady dine-in and takeout traffic, with prompt seating and quick delivery from the kitchen. Attentive, hardworking staff contribute to a smooth, casual dining experience.

Pizza Bruno is a Michelin-selected restaurant specializing in handcrafted pizzas, classic Italian starters, and simple desserts. Diners highlight its fragrant garlic knots, well-balanced Margherita pizza, and a thoughtful selection of local beers. The compact space offers both indoor and outdoor seating with upbeat music and a casual, energetic vibe, supported by attentive, efficient service.

Mellow Mushroom Orlando - International Drive specializes in flavorful pizzas, calzones, and fresh salads served in a lively, casual setting. Staff are noted for attentive, friendly service even when the restaurant is busy. The kitchen handles gluten-free, dairy-free, and other special orders with clear labeling and careful preparation, making it a comfortable choice for guests with dietary needs.

Mario's Pizza is a long-standing neighborhood spot known for classic pizzas, calzones, stromboli, and garlic knots. Guests highlight the consistently well-cooked dough, balanced red sauce, and generous selection of toppings. The modest, no-frills setting is complemented by attentive service and personable, hands-on owners. A reliable choice for dine-in or takeout comfort food.

Napoli Italian Pizzeria serves classic Italian-American favorites in a casual, no-frills setting. Guests highlight the Sicilian and Grandma-style pizzas, along with hearty spaghetti dishes and fresh salads. Counter service is efficient, and the welcoming staff create a familiar, neighborhood feel despite the compact dining area.

Cicis Pizza offers a casual, family-friendly buffet with a wide variety of pizzas, including rotating specialty and dessert options such as Boston cream pizza. Guests note consistently hot, flavorful pies, along with wings, Italian-style selections, and self-serve beverages. The spacious dining area accommodates groups easily, and the attentive staff and hands-on owner contribute to a welcoming, well-run experience.

Chuck E. Cheese offers a lively family destination combining casual pizza dining with a large selection of arcade games and simple rides for children of various ages. Guests mention helpful, organized staff who keep events running smoothly. Security measures at the entrance help ensure children leave only with their accompanying adults. Pizza, a salad bar, and beverages, including beer and wine, round out the experience.

Bella Italia Pizza is a small, independently run spot offering classic Italian dishes and New York–style pizzas. Guests highlight generously topped pies, along with calzones, stromboli, subs, and traditional pastas such as chicken piccata and marsala. The kitchen focuses on straightforward, well-prepared flavors, and the unpretentious, friendly setting reflects its neighborhood character.

Red Oven Pizza Bakery specializes in stone-baked pizzas with notably light, flavorful dough that guests often share family-style. Pies such as Italian-inspired meat toppings are cooked in a visible oven, emphasizing a simple, straightforward approach. The atmosphere is energetic and casual, and the staff is described as attentive and helpful, even during busy periods.