The Best Pizza Restaurants in Panama City Beach

Shore Shack Pizza

3.40(0 reviews)

USD 15

Italian / 4900 Thomas Dr, Panama City Beach, FL 32408-6920, United States /

Casual Spot for New York–Style Pizza

Shore Shack Pizza serves New York–style pies with fresh, house-made dough and a crisp, flavorful crust. Guests choose from classic and creative combinations, along with pasta dishes, subs, salads, and a few craft brews. The atmosphere is simple and relaxed, with options for indoor seating, a small patio, or takeout. Friendly, efficient staff contribute to an easygoing, welcoming experience.

Paparazzi Pizza

3.18(0 reviews)

USD 12

Italian / 2810 Thomas Dr, Panama City Beach, FL 32408-6248, United States /

Casual Italian Pizzeria and Eatery

Paparazzi Pizza serves classic Italian comfort food, from thin-crust, stone-baked pizzas to pasta, calzones, stromboli, and house-style desserts. Guests note the fresh, homemade character of the sauces and generous portions. A casual, unpretentious setting and attentive staff create an easygoing spot for enjoying hearty Italian favorites.

Nick's Slice Of Brooklyn Pizzeria And Bar

3.14(0 reviews)

USD 6

Italian / 13528 Front Beach Rd Parking In Shared Shopping Center, Panama City Beach, FL 32407-3325, United States /

Casual New York–Style Pizzeria and Bar

Nick's Slice Of Brooklyn Pizzeria And Bar serves classic New York–style pizza by the slice alongside stromboli, garlic knots, and Italian desserts like cannoli. Guests describe the atmosphere as unpretentious and welcoming, with a lively bar area for drinks and casual dining. Attentive, friendly service and consistently flavorful pizza and boli rolls define the experience.

Zollo's Pizza

3.00(0 reviews)

USD 14

Pizza / 14658 Front Beach Rd, Panama City Beach, FL 32413, United States /

Crispy Thin-Crust Pizza and Takeout Favorites

Zollo's Pizza specializes in crisp, super-thin crust pies with balanced sauce, chewy cheese, and finely chopped toppings. Guests note flavorful dough and generous portions, with options like cheesy garlic knots rounding out the menu. Efficient, friendly service and prompt order readiness make it a convenient spot for takeout pizza.

Island Pizza

3.00(0 reviews)

USD 22

Pizza / 541B N Richard Jackson Blvd Next to British Restaurant and Barefoot Fireworks across from Beach, Panama City Beach, FL 32407-3616, United States /

Late-Night Hand-Tossed Pizza

Island Pizza serves freshly made New York–style hand-tossed pies with a hint of thin-crust influence, along with familiar sides like garlic knots. This casual spot focuses on takeout and delivery, including late-night service that appeals to hungry night owls. Guests appreciate the flavorful crust and the delivery team’s effort to bring orders promptly, even in challenging conditions.

Cicis Pizza

3.00(0 reviews)

USD 15

Pizza / 493 Richard Jackson Boulevard Ste.523, Panama City Beach, FL 32407, United States /

Family-Friendly Pizza Buffet

Cicis Pizza offers a casual, family-oriented setting centered on a self-serve pizza and salad buffet. Guests highlight consistently hot, fresh pizzas, a well-stocked salad bar with fresh vegetables, and popular sweet options like cinnamon rolls. Staff are described as welcoming, attentive, and accommodating with special orders, contributing to an easygoing dining experience.