The Best American Restaurants in St Augustine Beach

Stir It Up is a laid-back beachside café offering fresh, straightforward fare like burritos, quesadillas, salads, sandwiches, and warm pitas. Smoothies and gluten- and dairy-free options cater to a range of preferences. Guests enjoy ordering from the window and relaxing on the porch, picnic tables, or hammocks just steps from the beach.

World Famous Oasis Restaurant & Tiki Bar is a laid-back spot known for approachable seafood and classic American comfort food. Guests highlight dishes like fried oysters, coconut shrimp, and shrimp tacos, along with indulgent waffle desserts. Service is described as quick and attentive, with a welcoming attitude toward both visitors and regulars. Occasional trivia nights add a lively, social element to the casual atmosphere.

Little Margie’s is a cozy, unpretentious spot known for hearty, homemade comfort food served from breakfast through dinner. Popular with locals, it offers classic plates such as seafood scrambles, fish sandwiches, and tacos, along with onion rings and a selection of beer and wine. Friendly, attentive service and both indoor and deck seating create an easygoing beachside atmosphere.

Little Margie’s FA Café is a small, casual spot near the beach offering a broad menu of comfort dishes. Guests highlight flavorful burgers, wings, sandwiches, and hearty breakfasts like biscuits and gravy, along with occasional seafood options such as crab legs. The café also serves simple vegetarian choices, including wraps and fries. Attentive, welcoming service and a laid-back, local feel define the experience.