The Best Bagel Restaurants in St. Augustine

Schmagel's Bagels is a compact bagel shop known for fresh, warm bagels and made-to-order breakfast sandwiches. House-made cream cheese and smooth cold brew coffee are popular choices. Guests often enjoy their meal on the covered patio, which adds a relaxed, historic ambiance, while attentive staff contribute to an easygoing start to the day.

Everything Bagel is a casual bagel shop known for its freshly made, thick, and fluffy bagels with a good variety of flavors. Guests highlight the generously topped bagels and sandwiches, including a popular lox and cream cheese option. Efficient counter service and self-serve coffee create a straightforward, laid-back start to the day.