The 20 Best Restaurants in Treasure Island

Salty Sisters Gourmet Popcorn specializes in gourmet popcorn with a wide range of flavors that regulars describe as richly seasoned and addictive. The shop offers gift tins and boxes that are popular for sharing and celebrations. Guests highlight the upbeat atmosphere and staff who are enthusiastic about their craft.

Shake Shop specializes in classic ice cream treats and hand-spun milkshakes, with flavors like strawberry and traditional vanilla drawing consistent praise. Sundaes and banana splits are prepared with balanced toppings and smooth, rich ice cream. Despite frequent lines, the young team works efficiently and remains attentive, including careful handling of allergy concerns.

Middle Grounds Grill offers a mix of grilled steaks and coastal seafood in a lively, welcoming setting. Guests highlight flavorful, herb-seasoned steaks, crisp calamari, and satisfying seafood pastas and chowders. Attentive service and a family-friendly atmosphere contribute to an enjoyable dining experience.

Ricky T's Bar & Grille offers a casual bar-and-grill experience with a focus on fresh seafood, including popular fish dishes and a notable grouper sandwich. Guests highlight crisp onion rings, well-made cocktails, and a menu with plenty of options. Live music and outdoor seating contribute to a lively, local west Florida vibe, with generally attentive service adding to the appeal.

Ka'Tiki Beach Bar & Restaurant is a casual beachfront tiki hut known for strong drinks, friendly bartenders, and an easygoing locals’ vibe. Guests gather for frequent live music, often featuring blues, and a lively crowd that sings along late into the evening. Classic bar fare, including substantial hamburgers, rounds out the relaxed, dive-bar style experience.

Foxy's Cafe offers classic American comfort food and hearty breakfast favorites in a laid-back neighborhood setting. Guests highlight dishes like the prime rib sandwich, sloppy joe, Denver omelette, and chocolate chip pancakes for their satisfying flavors. Friendly, attentive staff and generous portions contribute to its welcoming, down-to-earth atmosphere.

Bilmar Beach Cafe offers casual beachfront dining on Treasure Island, serving a broad selection of familiar breakfast, lunch, and dinner favorites. Guests highlight hearty morning plates, fresh salads, wraps, and seafood options. An outdoor area with oversized chairs and a fire pit provides a scenic spot for sunset views, while periodic live music and karaoke contribute to a lively, relaxed atmosphere.

Crabby's On The Pass offers casual seafood dining right on the Intracoastal Waterway, with frequent views of dolphins and boat traffic. Guests can sit outdoors to enjoy the waterfront setting, and boaters can tie up at the dock with on-site assistance. Service is noted as attentive and accommodating, with popular options like blackened fish sandwiches and house sauces.

This intimate Mexican-American eatery on Treasure Island serves generous portions of flavorful classics in a casual, welcoming setting. Guests highlight the house margaritas, homemade queso, and a range of dishes from tacos to steak and burrito bowls. Friendly, attentive service and a laid-back atmosphere make it a popular local gathering place.

Set within Treasure Island Beach Resort, BRGR Kitchen & Bar offers a stylish indoor dining room and a shaded terrace overlooking the pool and Gulf. The menu focuses on hearty burgers, fresh salads, and coastal-inspired plates, complemented by creative cocktails. Attentive, upbeat service contributes to a relaxed, resort-style experience.

Sloppy Joe's Treasure Island serves casual American fare with a focus on hearty sandwiches, slow-roasted pulled pork, and seafood-inspired plates. The namesake Sloppy Joe stands out with its housemade, chili-spiced sauce, often complemented by sides like loaded fries. Guests describe a laid-back beach atmosphere, with both table and bar seating contributing to its lively coastal feel.