The 20 Best Restaurants in Pocatello

Sandpiper Restaurant offers a classic steak and seafood experience in both a formal dining room and a more casual bistro-style space. Guests highlight well-prepared steaks, salmon, and escargot, along with distinctive touches such as a signature house salad dressing and thoughtfully served bread. A lively bar and lounge area, frequented by locals, and attentive, welcoming service contribute to its inviting atmosphere.

Elmer's Restaurant - Pocatello serves classic American comfort food, from hearty breakfast plates and omelets to generous prime rib dinners. Yukon Gold potatoes, biscuits, and seasonal vegetables are prepared with care and delivered hot. The welcoming staff provides prompt, efficient service, giving this chain location the feel of a well-loved local diner.

Pizza Pie Cafe offers a casual buffet focused on pizza, pasta, and a self-serve salad bar, giving guests plenty of options to customize their meal. The atmosphere is lively and popular with groups and families. Staff members are described as welcoming and helpful, and the food is noted as fresh even during busy periods.

Taste of India and Nepal serves classic Indian dishes with rich, well-balanced flavors, from creamy spinach and chicken to smoky eggplant and tender lamb curries. A varied buffet offers both meat and vegetarian options, complemented by fresh naan and traditional drinks. Attentive, welcoming staff contribute to a comfortable, enjoyable dining experience.

The College Market is a casual coffeehouse near campus known for its flavorful coffee and a broad selection of light café fare, including wraps, paninis, and salads. A favorite gathering spot for students and faculty, it offers a lively, conversational atmosphere. Guests appreciate the welcoming staff, along with books, games, and occasional game nights that add to the social feel of the space.

Big Foot Pizza is a carry-out pizzeria known for its consistently flavorful pies over many years. Guests highlight well-balanced toppings, thin crisp crust, and reliably prepared pizzas. Orders are ready quickly, and the staff provide helpful, welcoming service for an easy takeout experience.

Thai Kitchen serves a broad selection of classic Thai dishes in a small, clean, and comfortable dining room. Guests highlight consistently flavorful food and efficient, courteous service, whether dining in or using the restaurant’s catering for larger gatherings. Spice levels can be adjusted to taste, and portions are described as generous and satisfying.

Goody's offers a casual deli experience with made-to-order subs, sandwiches, and pizzas, with meats and cheeses sliced to order and a choice of breads. Guests note hot, flavorful food, a wide selection of drinks, and beer on tap. Friendly, efficient service and a mix of indoor and outdoor seating create a comfortable place to linger, with occasional trivia nights and live music adding to the lively atmosphere.