The Best Restaurants in Cicero, Indiana

Delullo's Trattoria offers traditional Italian cooking with a comforting, homestyle touch, from handmade breadsticks and fresh salads to generous pasta dishes. House specialties such as cannelloni and seafood lasagna are frequently praised for their rich flavor. Guests describe a relaxed, welcoming dining room and attentive, knowledgeable service that enhances the overall experience.

Erika's Place offers classic American comfort food with a focus on hearty breakfast and brunch favorites. Guests describe well-prepared dishes such as omelets, eggs Benedict, and homestyle potatoes. The small dining room has a cozy, local feel, and the staff provides prompt, welcoming service that makes many visitors feel like regulars.

Pizza House is a local pizzeria known for flavorful pies made with quality ingredients. Guests highlight classic and specialty pizzas alongside breadsticks and wings with rich sauces. The staff is described as attentive, pleasant, and quick to resolve any issues. A personable management style contributes to a welcoming neighborhood feel.

Big Dog's Smokehouse BBQ serves classic American barbecue in a funky, eclectic setting near downtown Cicero. Diners highlight the tender sliced brisket, pulled pork sandwiches, and hearty sides like mac and cheese. The relaxed indoor and outdoor spaces and welcoming staff create an easygoing spot for casual meals, while the restaurant also provides catering for larger events.

La Cascada offers classic Mexican and American-Mex dishes in a casual, family-friendly setting with roomy booths and seasonal patio seating. Guests are welcomed with chips and salsa, including a spicy house version, and can choose from familiar favorites alongside specialties like garlic shrimp, tilapia, and hearty mixed-grill platters. TVs often tuned to soccer and partial water views create a relaxed neighborhood atmosphere.