The 20 Best Sandwich Restaurants in Indianapolis

Don Juan V's Peruvian Sandwiches specializes in hearty Peruvian-style sandwiches served on house-made buns, with favorites like lomo saltado and chicharron. Crisp fries and empanadas round out the menu. Guests are greeted by a welcoming team, with the option of counter service or table seating. An open kitchen and lively music create an energetic, casual atmosphere.

Located in the City Market, Cafe Olivia specializes in made-to-order sandwiches and panini, with options like roast beef and Cubano-style combinations frequently noted by guests. Ingredients are described as fresh, with warm breads and flavorful meats. A self-serve salad bar offers an additional option for a quick, satisfying lunch amid the lively market setting.

bbi Cafe & Sandwich Shop is a casual, family-run spot offering an extensive menu of sandwiches, gyros, fish tacos, and classic breakfast plates. Guests highlight the fresh, flavorful food and well-seasoned sides. The dining room is kept clean, and service is attentive and efficient, creating a pleasant, easygoing experience.

McAlister's Deli offers a broad selection of deli-style favorites, including sandwiches, salads, soups, and large baked potatoes. Guests highlight the fresh ingredients, flavorful iced teas and lemonades, and appealing pick-two combinations. Friendly, attentive staff bring orders to the table and check in throughout the meal, while ample seating and a pleasant patio add to the comfortable experience.

McAlister's Deli offers a casual setting for classic deli favorites, including sandwiches, salads, soups, and baked treats. Guests highlight fresh, well-prepared food and a popular tea bar for easy refills. The restaurant features outdoor seating and a private room for groups, with a clean, well-kept dining area and efficient counter service.

Greiner's SubShop serves generous hot and cold subs, pizzas, and classic sides in a modern industrial-style space. Diners highlight the substantial sandwiches, crisp fries, and popular mac and cheese variations, along with flavorful breadsticks and marinara. Friendly, responsive service and freshly baked goods, including treats for dogs, round out the casual, satisfying experience.

Potbelly Sandwich Shop serves hearty toasted sandwiches and soups in a compact, bustling space that evokes a classic city eatery. Favorites include meatball and pizza-style sandwiches, prepared to order with customizable toppings. The welcoming staff and the aroma of grilling fillings create an inviting break in the heart of the city, with some locations also offering the convenience of a drive-thru.