The 20 Best Restaurants in Salem, Indiana

The Soda Fountain at Salem Apothecary offers a nostalgic experience inside a traditional pharmacy setting on the town square. Guests enjoy classic treats such as ice cream, root beer floats, sodas, and a simple daily lunch special. The space is described as clean, quaint, and visually interesting, with welcoming staff and a loyal local following.

H & R Bakery is a long-standing local bakeshop in Salem known for fresh donuts, fritters, and filled pastries. Guests appreciate the soft, freshly made dough and variety of classic sweets. The bakery also serves coffee from Sunergos Coffee, creating a simple, satisfying stop for pastries and a drink.

Now known as Thai Lotus, this restaurant serves classic Thai cuisine with customizable spice levels and consistently flavorful dishes. A remodeled dining room and smooth jazz create a comfortable atmosphere, complemented by attentive, unobtrusive service. Lunch specials are thoughtfully presented and often include soup, salad, and a small roll, while a selection of wines is also available.

Nice's Family Diner offers classic American comfort food in a traditional family-style setting. Guests mention hearty favorites such as country fried steak, fried chicken, salads, and generous breakfast plates, along with homemade-style pies and cakes. Service is described as welcoming and attentive, and the relaxed atmosphere makes it a comfortable spot to linger over a meal.

The Destination combines a peaceful inn setting with satisfying homemade cuisine. Guests highlight a generous, well-prepared breakfast and thoughtful touches like fresh baked goods and hot coffee. The catering service provides appealing, flavorful dishes with all necessary accompaniments, making it suitable for workplace events and gatherings. A calm atmosphere and tidy surroundings complete the experience.

Located on the courthouse square in downtown Salem, El Maguey Mexican Restaurant serves classic Mexican dishes in a bustling, casual setting. Guests highlight fresh chips and salsa, house-made guacamole, and hearty plates like burritos and arroz con carne, along with generous beverages. Attentive, efficient service keeps the dining room moving even during busy periods.

Express China offers a well-stocked Chinese buffet complemented by a selection of sushi and classic desserts such as almond cookies and ice cream. Dishes are described as hot, fresh, and varied enough to satisfy different tastes. The family-run staff is attentive without rushing guests, and the dining room suits both small parties and larger groups in a comfortable, hometown setting.