The Best Restaurants in Stonington, Maine

Fin and Fern is a small coastal restaurant specializing in fresh seafood, from local oysters to simply prepared fish like halibut and swordfish. Guests describe the space as cozy and appealing, with an inviting patio and an intimate upstairs area by the bar. Attentive, welcoming service and a relaxed atmosphere make it a comfortable spot to linger over dinner and dessert.

Stonington Ice Cream Company pairs classic New England seafood with house ice cream in a simple, walk-up setting. Fresh lobster rolls, lightly dressed and generously filled, are a highlight, alongside other casual seafood options. A changing selection of ice cream flavors offers a sweet finish, with a few outdoor seats and easy access to harbor views nearby.

The Cockatoo Portuguese Restaurant offers classic Portuguese dishes and coastal seafood in an intimate waterfront setting. Freshly caught fish, lobster, and shellfish anchor the menu, highlighted by specialties such as hearty seafood stew and traditional fish preparations. Guests describe the space as small and quaint, with attentive, accommodating service that enhances the relaxed oceanfront atmosphere.

Stonecutters Kitchen is a casual harborfront spot offering generous portions of classic New England–style seafood and familiar pub favorites. Diners order at the counter and choose from indoor tables, bar seating, or the outdoor deck overlooking the water. Fresh haddock dishes, lobster rolls, and chilled draft beer highlight the straightforward, satisfying menu, supported by efficient, attentive service.