The Best Bakery Restaurants in Amherst, Massachusetts

The Black Sheep is a long-established scratch bakery and café known for fresh breads, pastries, and an extensive selection of made-to-order sandwiches. The space offers a cozy, local feel, with a welcoming counter team and quick service even when busy. In addition to its café offerings, the bakery provides catering with generous platters and desserts for off-site events, including delivery to nearby venues.