The Best American Restaurants in Chilmark, Massachusetts

Menemsha Galley is a casual, window-service spot known for its lobster rolls, burgers, sandwiches, and hot fries. Guests enjoy simple, well-prepared seafood and grill favorites, along with soft-serve ice cream. Friendly staff and scenic views, including nods to local film history, create a relaxed coastal atmosphere.

Homeport Restaurant & Oyster Bar offers classic New England seafood with an emphasis on fresh, locally harvested oysters and simply prepared fish and lobster. Guests dine in a casual, come-as-you-are setting with views over Menemsha Pond, especially striking at sunset. The atmosphere is relaxed and unpretentious, with attentive staff and a straightforward, maritime feel. A selection of desserts, including house pies and cobbler, rounds out the meal.