The 20 Best Restaurants in Beach Haven

Set within a historic inn, The Gables Historic Inn & Restaurant offers refined contemporary American cuisine in a lush, flower-filled setting. Guests can dine on the porch, in the garden, or in an intimate dining room while enjoying thoughtfully prepared seafood, steaks, and rich desserts. A prix-fixe format encourages a leisurely, multi-course meal. Attentive service and live piano music create a polished, celebratory atmosphere.

Barry's Do Me A Flavor is a casual outdoor eatery known for satisfying sandwiches, housemade chips, and classic ice cream treats. Friendly, energetic staff keep the line moving while serving both breakfast and lunch favorites. In the mornings, the space also hosts a community-focused café operated by staff with developmental disabilities, adding a meaningful dimension to the experience.

Black Whale Bar & Fish House offers a lively setting for classic seafood favorites, from fresh oysters and crab cakes to rotating fish specials. House-made salad dressings and a well-regarded dessert selection add to the appeal. Attentive, knowledgeable service and a strong cocktail program complete the experience in this popular gathering place.

Parker's Garage & Oyster Saloon offers inventive seafood and small plates in a lively waterfront setting. Dishes such as grilled shrimp, calamari, Brussels sprouts, and octopus are prepared with creative sauces and textures. A chef’s tasting menu highlights the kitchen’s range, while attentive staff guide guests through the options. The restaurant operates as a bring-your-own wine venue.

Uncle Will's is a popular breakfast destination known for its wide range of classic American morning dishes, from specialty omelets and Benedicts to light, fluffy pancakes and waffles. The atmosphere is lively and family-friendly, and the staff handles crowds and large groups with efficiency. Well-prepared plates and quick service make it a reliable choice for a relaxed breakfast in Beach Haven.

Pearl Street Market is a small neighborhood spot offering freshly made sandwiches, salads, wraps, panini, and hearty breakfast items. Highlights include generously filled lobster BLTs, flavorful steak and shrimp options, and a well-regarded breakfast burrito. Guests also find quality coffee and a selection of fresh seafood to take home. Service is attentive and welcoming, adding to the easygoing market atmosphere.

Bird and Betty's offers casual American fare with an emphasis on seafood, pizza, and classic comfort dishes. Guests mention well-prepared favorites such as octopus appetizers, oysters, and scallop plates, along with creative cocktails. A lively bar, outdoor deck, and wide bay views at sunset create a vibrant setting that often features music and dancing.

Ship Bottom Brewery offers a rotating selection of craft beers, from hop-forward IPAs to creative seasonal releases like dessert-inspired ales and stouts. Guests can sample a range of brews with tasting flights or enjoy a pint while overlooking the surrounding area. The taproom features a sociable, laid-back atmosphere, often enhanced by live entertainment.

The Coffee Bouteaque is a quaint coffeehouse known for smooth coffee, specialty lattes, and a wide range of teas and smoothies. Guests also find fresh organic juice blends and refreshing acai and pitaya bowls. The atmosphere is relaxed and upbeat, with staff who are attentive, helpful, and eager to tailor drinks to individual preferences.

Shore Good Donuts specializes in freshly made donuts finished to order with a wide range of toppings, creams, and icings. Guests can build their own combinations or choose from classic pairings, along with a rotating weekly specialty. Warm donuts and breakfast sandwiches contribute to a casual, satisfying start to the day.

Crust & Crumb Bakery is a long-standing Beach Haven favorite, known for its nostalgic appeal and generous baked goods. The bakery specializes in classic treats such as elephant ears, crumb cake, croissants, and cookies, noted for their rich flavor and satisfying texture. It remains a familiar stop for visitors returning to Long Beach Island year after year.

The Chicken or the Egg – Beach Haven serves hearty American comfort food from breakfast through dinner in a casual, welcoming setting. Guests highlight substantial omelets, classic turkey dinners, and creamy New England clam chowder, along with other diner-style staples. Friendly service, a clean dining room, and slightly quirky décor contribute to its easygoing appeal.

Crêperie de la Mer & French Café offers a taste of France on Long Beach Island with made-to-order sweet and savory crêpes. Guests find options ranging from a Monte Cristo-style crêpe to versions with smoked salmon and lemon dill crème fraîche, alongside classic sweet combinations. The compact bistro-style space includes a few indoor and outdoor tables, creating an intimate, casual setting. A selection of teas, French press coffee, specialty iced coffees, and smoothies complements the menu.

How You Brewin Coffee Company offers thoughtfully crafted coffee drinks, from robust house roasts to frappes and nitro cold brew, along with non-dairy options. Guests find a selection of light café fare, including soups, sandwiches, and baked goods with vegan choices. The remodeled space is clean, comfortable, and inviting, with a charming atmosphere that suits the neighborhood and occasional live music.

Lenny and John’s Subs is a casual, family-run deli on Long Beach Island known for its generous sandwiches and classic breakfast egg sandwiches. Fresh bread and Brooklyn bagels are brought in daily, giving the subs a distinct New York–style character. Signature options like the tuna sub highlight the shop’s straightforward, satisfying approach to deli favorites.