The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Mexico

Tiffany's Pizza & Greek Cuisine offers a mix of Greek dishes and classic comfort favorites, with gyros, hummus with pita, and chicken Parmesan often praised for their flavor. Guests highlight consistently well-prepared food and attention to detail, including careful packaging for takeout. The atmosphere is casual and lively, with staff and on-site owners creating a personable, neighborhood feel.

Slice and Dice Pizzeria combines classic pizzeria favorites with a large selection of board games for a playful dining experience. Guests enjoy oven-fresh pizzas, salads, and appetizers such as stuffed mushrooms and burrata with spinach. Bright, casual interiors and attentive staff create a lively setting that especially appeals to game enthusiasts and families.

Bravo! Italian Kitchen serves familiar Italian favorites, from hearty pastas and pizzas to chicken and seafood dishes, prepared with attention to freshness and flavor. Guests note attentive, polished service and a classy, well-kept dining room suitable for gatherings. Thoughtful packaging and presentation also make it a reliable choice for takeout.

Forrest's Pizza specializes in hand-tossed pies baked in a gas-fired oven, known for their well-browned, crisp crusts. Guests highlight the quality cheese, flavorful Italian sausage, and generous salads such as the Greek salad. The overall experience centers on straightforward, satisfying pizza in a simple, unpretentious setting.

Dion's is a casual spot known for its hearty pizzas, crisp salads, and generously filled subs. Guests highlight the distinctive New Mexico touch of green chile on pizza and flavorful marinara sauce. Fresh salads, including variations with chicken and specialty dressings, and classic hot subs such as meatball are frequent favorites, making it a popular choice for relaxed, satisfying meals.

Dion's is a casual spot known for its hearty pizzas, generously topped and built on a slightly thicker crust. Guests also appreciate the fresh salads and classic sandwiches, often highlighted with house dressings like Greek and green chile ranch. The restaurant is popular for takeout, and even offers pizza dough for those who want to bake at home.

Dion's offers consistently well-made pizza in a clean, comfortable setting. Guests highlight the fresh, flavorful crust and generous toppings, with portions that are easy to share. Friendly, efficient staff keep service smooth, even during busy periods, making it a reliable spot for relaxed, casual meals.

Dion’s is a casual counter-service spot known for its consistently fresh pizza, hearty subs, and crisp salads. Guests highlight the soft, flavorful dough and the option to add local green chile to their pies. Service is typically quick and courteous, whether dining in or using the convenient drive-up pickup window.

Dion’s offers classic, satisfying pizzas and fresh salads, often noted for their flavorful house dressing. Guests describe the atmosphere as clean and comfortable, with a straightforward, family-friendly feel. The staff provides friendly, efficient service, and many appreciate the convenient ordering and pickup options for takeout.

Dion's Pizza offers classic pizzas, sandwiches, and generous salads in a bright, bustling dining room with plenty of seating. Guests highlight the fresh salads and distinctive house-made dressings, including Greek, Caesar, and blue cheese, which are also available by the bottle. Made-to-order pizzas and self-serve fountain drinks contribute to an easygoing, family-friendly experience.

Restoration Pizza serves classic and specialty pizzas, fresh salads, and appetizers, complemented by a full bar and local brews. Diners mention crisp crusts, flavorful toppings, and satisfying portions. The restaurant’s mission-centered approach provides employment opportunities for people with differing abilities, creating a welcoming, community-oriented atmosphere.

Dion's Pizza serves classic thin-crust pies with ample cheese and toppings, along with large, crisp salads made from fresh ingredients. Guests highlight consistently good quality and generous portions. The staff is noted for its upbeat, courteous service, and the dining area is kept impressively clean.

Dion’s Pizza is a busy counter-service pizzeria known for consistently well-prepared pies and generous salads. Guests watch the team assemble orders in an open kitchen, while the spacious dining area is kept orderly and clean. Popular choices include combination pizzas and large shared salads with housemade dressings, including a green chile ranch that many guests highlight.

Dion’s is a local New Mexico chain known for its consistently well-made pizza, hot subs, and fresh salads. Guests highlight the flavorful dough, soft sub bread, and signature salad mix, often paired with the house ranch dressing, which is also bottled. A family-friendly atmosphere includes views into the kitchen, where children can watch pizzas being prepared.

Jemez Mountain Brewhouse specializes in handcrafted pizzas made with fresh, house-prepared dough and quality toppings, including hearty meat combinations. Guests pair their meals with an extensive selection of regional beers and ciders. The casual, welcoming setting and attentive staff create a relaxed stop for hikers and travelers exploring the surrounding area.

Dion's offers classic pizzas and generous salads in a casual, family-friendly setting. Guests highlight the consistently fresh ingredients, from simple cheese pies to Greek-style salads with crisp lettuce and olives. The staff is known for being attentive and efficient, and the space comfortably accommodates both everyday meals and larger groups.

Dion's serves classic pizza, generously filled sandwiches, and substantial made-to-order salads in a casual, family-friendly setting. Guests highlight the flavorful crusts, customizable pizzas, and signature salads such as the chef and Greek variations. Quick, efficient service and ample seating make it a convenient option for groups and teams.

Dion’s serves classic New York–style thin-crust pizza alongside toasted subs and simple fresh sides. Signature options include specialty slices and regional toppings like green chile. The dining room is kept clean and orderly, and staff are described as friendly and attentive, often going out of their way to correct any issues with orders.