The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Albany, New York

Navona offers Italian-inspired cuisine with a focus on fresh flavors, including wood-fired pizzas, classic sandwiches, and salads. A modern, softly styled interior and generally quiet dining room create a comfortable setting for both lunch and dinner. Attentive, friendly service and a thoughtfully crafted menu contribute to an enjoyable, relaxed meal.

DC's Pizza & Catering is known for consistently well-prepared pizza that arrives hot, whether picked up or delivered. Beyond pizza, the menu features hearty subs, burgers, sandwiches, and fish and chips, including a house-style eggplant Parmesan and a turkey sandwich with sweet and savory accents. The restaurant offers a straightforward, family-friendly take on classic comfort food.

Golden Grain Pizza Colonie serves classic and specialty pizzas alongside items such as garlic knots, Greek salad, and gyros. Guests note a modern, inviting interior with a prominent fireplace and a display of fresh pizzas at the counter. Delivery orders arrive in good condition, and staff are described as attentive and helpful.

Blaze Pizza specializes in made-to-order, personal pizzas prepared quickly in a casual setting. Guests choose their own toppings, with options that include vegan cheese and a variety of vegetables and meats. Staff members are described as efficient and friendly, and the dining area is kept clean, making it a convenient spot for a satisfying pizza meal.

Inferno Pizzeria offers classic Italian-American fare, from generously topped pizzas to hearty pasta dinners and antipasto. Guests note flavorful, light-crusted pizza, tender garlic knots, and portions substantial enough for leftovers. The space is simple and clean, with a small dining room, patio tables in good weather, and steady takeout and delivery activity, creating an unfussy, local spot feel.

I Love NY Pizza serves classic New York–style pies, slices, and strombolis with a focus on fresh, consistently made dough and toppings. Guests highlight the reliable quality whether ordering a quick slice or a full pizza for a group. Attentive, personable staff and convenient takeout and delivery contribute to its role as a longstanding neighborhood favorite in Colonie.

Pizzeria Sapienza serves classic New York–style pizza, available by the slice or as whole pies, with a crisp yet chewy crust and a flavorful homemade sauce. Generous, freshly baked slices, including options like veggie or buffalo chicken, are a highlight. The bustling downtown shop is often busy, but service remains quick and efficient.