The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Astoria, New York

Astoria Pizza Factory serves classic New York–style and Sicilian pizza in a casual, counter-service setting. A wide range of ready-made specialty slices, from Buffalo chicken to Caesar salad pizza, makes it easy to grab something quickly. Guests note flavorful combinations and a satisfying crust, with a steady local following even late in the day.

Pronto Pizzeria offers classic Italian cooking in a compact, convivial space with a welcoming, family-style feel. Guests describe generous portions of comforting dishes, from crisp garlic bread and fresh salads to hearty pasta and pizza. Attentive, good-humored service and a relaxed pace encourage lingering over a meal with wine and dessert.

Grand Avenue Pizza serves classic New York–style pies and slices in a straightforward neighborhood setting in Astoria. Reviewers highlight the well-balanced sauce and cheese, especially on the Sicilian slice, along with flavorful specialty options like Buffalo chicken and penne vodka on focaccia. Consistent quality and generous toppings make it a local favorite for casual pizza cravings.

Rizzo's Pizza is a long-standing Astoria pizzeria known for its distinctive thin-crust pies, especially the signature square Sicilian slices. Guests appreciate the light, crisp crusts, fresh toppings, and house-made specialties such as garlic knots and cannoli. A clean, classic interior and welcoming counter service create a comfortable neighborhood feel.

Tufino Pizzeria offers classic Italian comfort food, featuring crisp, flavorful pizzas and housemade pasta such as bucatini. A margherita D.O.C. and specialty pies with sausage and cheese highlight the kitchen’s range. Attentive staff and an accommodating chef create a personable, relaxed dining experience in this inviting neighborhood spot.

Napoli Pizza & Pasta is a small, cozy eatery known for its flavorful pizza, including hearty Sicilian-style pies. The menu also features comforting pasta dishes, salads, and classic appetizers like garlic bread and zeppole. Open-air seating near the patio doors and sports on television create an easygoing, welcoming setting that feels like a neighborhood favorite.