Big Papa's3.38(0 reviews)Seafood / 121 Greenwood St, Canisteo, NY 14823, United States / New China Restaurant3.18(0 reviews)USD 15Chinese / 21 Main St, Canisteo, NY 14823, United States / Canisteo Pizzeria3.00(0 reviews)Pizza / 31 Main St, Canisteo, NY 14823-1125, United States /
The Best Restaurants in New York, New York - SeafoodView allMermaid Oyster Bar4.11(0 reviews)USD 22Seafood / 10849.7 km from Nearby searchCrave Fishbar3.86(0 reviews)USD 40Seafood / 10848.4 km from Nearby searchOceans3.55(0 reviews)USD 72Seafood / 10849.4 km from Nearby searchSelected by the Michelin in 2025Selected by the Michelin in 2025Selected by the Michelin in 2024The Clam3.46(0 reviews)USD 75Seafood / 10849.4 km from Nearby searchMolyvos3.43(0 reviews)USD 40Seafood / 10847.0 km from Nearby searchTemple Court3.33(0 reviews)USD 170Seafood / 10851.3 km from Nearby searchFlex Mussels3.45(0 reviews)USD 30Seafood / 10846.9 km from Nearby searchtheBoil3.37(0 reviews)USD 75Seafood / 10849.9 km from Nearby search
The Best Restaurants in Montauk - SeafoodView allWestlake Fish House3.00(0 reviews)USD 40Seafood / 10892.8 km from Nearby searchGrey Lady3.00(0 reviews)Seafood / 10892.2 km from Nearby search
.jpg?format=webp)
.jpg?format=webp)
.jpg?format=webp)
.jpg?format=webp)
.jpg?format=webp)
.jpg?format=webp)
.jpg?format=webp)
