The Best Pizza Restaurants in Cortland, New York

Pudgie's Pizza

3.00(0 reviews)

Pizza / 75 N Main St, Cortland, NY 13045, United States /

Lively Neighborhood Pizzeria and Takeout

Pudgie's Pizza is a busy neighborhood spot known for its classic pizzas, wings, and stromboli. Guests often order ahead for family meals and gatherings, with the kitchen working efficiently through heavy traffic. Staff handle call-in orders and timed pickups smoothly, creating a convenient option for takeout. The casual, familiar setting adds to its appeal as a local favorite.

Pontillo's Pizzeria Cortland

3.00(0 reviews)

USD 15

Pizza / 124 Groton Ave, Cortland, NY 13045, United States /

Casual Pizzeria and Italian-American Fare

Pontillo's Pizzeria Cortland serves classic New York–style pizza with a crisp crust, rich tomato sauce, and generous cheese. The menu extends to familiar Italian-American favorites such as chicken Parmesan, pasta dishes, subs, salads, and garlic knots. Guests describe the dining room as clean and comfortable, with generally prompt, attentive service that can slow slightly during busy periods.