The Best Pizza Restaurants in Fishkill

Florina's Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta offers classic Italian-American dishes centered on its wood-fired pizzas and hearty pastas. Guests highlight specialty pies with inventive toppings, along with well-prepared favorites like chicken scarpariello, fried calamari, and meatball heroes. Made-to-order stromboli and a range of toppings add to the variety. Attentive, personable service contributes to the welcoming neighborhood feel.

Pizza Phil is a casual pizzeria known for its consistently satisfying New York–style pies and substantial calzones. Guests highlight the flavorful combinations, including classic pizza toppings, garlic knots, and hearty hot sandwiches. The counter-service space is kept clean, and the staff is described as friendly and accommodating, making it a reliable choice for takeout or a quick meal.

Sal's Pizza & Pasta offers classic Italian-American comfort food, with consistently praised thin-crust pizza, fresh slices, and specialties like eggplant rollatini. An inviting outdoor patio and recently updated interior create a relaxed setting for lingering over a meal and a glass of wine. Friendly, accommodating service and attention to detail contribute to a welcoming neighborhood feel.