The Best Restaurants in Mastic Beach

Onofrio's is a long-established, family-run Italian restaurant known for hearty portions and classic comfort dishes. Diners highlight flavorful pizza with a rich, thick sauce, as well as traditional favorites like eggplant Parmesan, chicken Marsala, and pasta with Alfredo or clam sauce. The setting is small and softly lit, with welcoming staff and occasional live acoustic music creating a relaxed neighborhood feel.

New Rooster Kitchen serves made-to-order Chinese takeout in a clean, straightforward setting. Diners note the fresh preparation and generous portions, with a wide range of classic dishes alongside a dedicated vegetarian menu. Options such as General Tso’s vegetarian “chicken” stand out for their satisfying flavor. Service is efficient, whether ordering ahead or on arrival.