The Best Pizza Restaurants in Middletown, New York

Pizza E Birra offers classic Italian comfort dishes in a casual, welcoming setting. Guests highlight thin-crust pizzas, fresh-tasting pasta and a popular fried zucchini appetizer. Attentive, efficient service and an extensive craft beer list with cocktails create an easygoing place to relax and enjoy a satisfying meal.

Caputo’s Pizza is a downtown Middletown pizzeria offering a broad selection of classic pies and Italian-American dishes, available for both dine-in and catering. Guests highlight the flavorful pizza, including custom-topped personal pies and chicken bruschetta. The atmosphere is casual and bustling, with staff known for attentive, accommodating service that keeps many locals returning regularly.