The 20 Best Restaurants in Monroe, New York

Tequila Grille offers an eclectic, all-American menu with global touches, ranging from hearty grills to pasta and casual favorites, with gluten-free options available. The lively, welcoming dining room has a casual, small-town feel, set by a local golf course. Guests highlight flavorful dishes, robust margaritas, and consistently personable, attentive service, often with the owner present in the dining room.

Wayback Burgers offers classic American fast-casual fare in a clean, well-kept setting. Juicy burgers, crispy fries, onion rings, and hand-spun milkshakes are favorites, with chicken options and house-made chips also noted. Staff members are attentive and welcoming, and the restaurant shows a strong sense of pride and connection to the local community.

Captain's Table offers casual dining with hearty portions of seafood and American comfort food, from shrimp baskets to fish and chips. Guests highlight flavorful dishes, a good selection of drinks, and kid-friendly options. Attentive, upbeat service and the option for outdoor seating create a lively setting for relaxed meals with friends or family.

Plum House Japanese Restaurant offers a broad Japanese menu, from fresh sushi and sashimi to ramen, teriyaki dishes, and fried appetizers. Diners highlight the quality of the sushi and flavorful miso soup. The staff provides attentive, enthusiastic service, explaining specials and checking in frequently. A cozy dining room with updated decor and street views adds to the appeal for locals.

Amendola's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a long-standing, family-run Italian spot known for generous portions and consistently flavorful dishes. Guests praise the classic pizza, calzones, lasagna, and chicken and shrimp specialties. The atmosphere is informal and welcoming, with attentive, efficient service that adds to the comfortable neighborhood feel.

Scalia & Co Craft Kitchen and Bar is a family-owned Italian restaurant offering classic comfort dishes such as seafood pastas, lobster ravioli, and chicken specialties. The bar prepares well-balanced cocktails, including carefully made martinis. A compact, lively dining room and personable, professional staff create a welcoming neighborhood atmosphere.

Empire Diner offers classic American diner fare with generously portioned comfort dishes, from hearty meatloaf and grilled chicken to all-day breakfast plates. The extensive menu includes favorites like eggs Benedict and rich cheesecake desserts. Retro-style decor and welcoming staff create a lively, neighborly atmosphere where guests linger over coffee and conversation.

Okaeri Sushi Hibachi offers a mix of hibachi, sushi, and Chinese-style dishes in a comfortable, modern setting. Guests can choose a traditional table or join the hibachi grills, where chefs prepare meals with an entertaining flair. Sushi, hibachi combos, and soups are noted for fresh flavors and well-balanced seasoning, creating a satisfying dining experience.

Somni NY Tapas offers a menu of tapas-style small plates, from seafood favorites to comforting sides, complemented by popular sangria and other drinks. The interior features spacious dining rooms with rich wooden tables and a polished, contemporary feel. Attentive staff explain the menu clearly and accommodate groups, making it a fitting choice for relaxed meals and special gatherings.

Yune's Sushi offers an elegant, calming interior that contrasts with its modest exterior. The extensive menu features fresh sushi alongside cooked Japanese favorites and a selection of Korean dishes such as bibimbop. Guests can sit at the sushi bar to watch the chefs at work or enjoy full table service. Attentive staff and consistently well-prepared dishes create a polished dining experience.

La Vera Cucina offers classic Italian cuisine in a setting reminiscent of a Tuscan villa, with both indoor seating and a veranda for outdoor dining in suitable weather. Housemade pastas, veal specialties, steaks, and seafood are prepared with attention to flavor and presentation. Italian music and a welcoming atmosphere create a relaxed, intimate experience. Desserts, including sorbets, provide a satisfying finish to the meal.

Villa Positano is a family-run Italian restaurant and pizzeria offering a traditional, “old world” menu in a comfortable dining room. Guests choose between a casual front pizza counter and a more formal sit-down area in the back. Generous portions, flavorful classic dishes, and attentive service create a homelike atmosphere, complemented at times by comedy dinner shows.

Angelo's Sicilian Trattoria is a small, family-run spot offering hearty Sicilian and Italian comfort food in a casual, pond-side setting. The kitchen focuses on homestyle recipes and made-to-order pasta that arrives hot and fresh. A few closely set tables, a relaxed BYOB policy, and a steady takeout trade create an unpretentious, neighborhood trattoria feel.