The Best Pizza Restaurants in Oceanside, New York

Pizzaiola

3.00(0 reviews)

USD 15

Pizza / 3191 Long Beach Rd, Oceanside, NY 11572, United States /

Neighborhood New York–Style Pizzeria and Italian Eatery

Pizzaiola serves classic New York–style pizza with a well-crafted crust and flavorful melted cheese, alongside a broad selection of Italian staples. Guests highlight its fresh antipasto, hearty homemade soups, and satisfying sandwiches and pasta dishes. The space is modest in size, fostering a casual, neighborhood feel where many diners return regularly.

Lia's pizzeria Oceanside

3.03(0 reviews)

Pizza / 60 Atlantic Ave, Oceanside, NY 11572, United States /

Neighborhood Pizzeria with Classic Italian Favorites

Lia's pizzeria Oceanside serves New York–style pies alongside classic Italian favorites such as hot hero sandwiches, penne alla vodka, garlic knots, and fresh Caesar salad. The dining room offers both front and rear seating areas, creating a casual spot for families and groups. Attentive, welcoming staff and consistently well-prepared dishes make it a dependable choice for local pizza and pasta.

Villa Formia of Oceanside

3.00(0 reviews)

USD 15

Pizza / 136 Mott St, Oceanside, NY 11572, United States /

Neighborhood Italian Pizza and Pasta

Villa Formia of Oceanside offers classic Italian cooking with a focus on authentic pizza, hearty pastas, and comforting soups. Favorites include a flavorful buffalo chicken slice, a well-balanced whole wheat vegetable pie, and tortellini or Italian wedding soup served with fresh bread and garlic knots. Friendly service and a welcoming, local feel define the experience.