The Best Restaurants in Sherburne

Gilligan's Island

3.91(0 reviews)

USD 10

American / 64 N Main St, Sherburne, NY 13460-9563, United States /

Roadside Burgers and Ice Cream

Gilligan's Island is a casual roadside stop known for its burgers, fries, and a wide selection of ice cream flavors served in cones, bowls, and sundaes. Guests appreciate the option of vegetarian burgers alongside charbroiled specials. Friendly counter and drive-thru service and outdoor picnic seating create an informal, laid-back setting, with classic car nights adding extra charm in warm weather.

Columbus Public House

3.94(0 reviews)

USD 15

American / 4301 State route 80, Sherburne, NY 13460-3603, United States /

Lewis' Restaurant

3.24(0 reviews)

USD 15

Italian / 93 North Main Street, Sherburne, NY 13460-9516, United States /

Comforting Italian and Seafood Classics

Lewis' Restaurant serves hearty Italian‑American favorites and seafood in a welcoming, family‑oriented setting. Guests highlight dishes such as stuffed shells, lasagna, broiled haddock, and scallops, along with familiar sides. Service is described as quick and friendly, creating an easygoing atmosphere for both everyday meals and relaxed gatherings.