The 20 Best Ice Cream Restaurants in Columbus, Ohio

Graeter’s Ice Cream is a classic Midwestern ice cream parlor known for rich, creamy scoops and indulgent sundaes. Guests highlight flavors with chunks of chocolate and mix-ins, including s’mores-inspired creations, as particular favorites. Friendly, attentive staff and nostalgic traditions give the shop a welcoming, neighborhood feel for both locals and visitors.

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams offers rich, ultra-creamy ice cream in a variety of inventive flavors, from dark chocolate to brown butter almond brittle and goat cheese with cherries. Guests can sample flavors before choosing a cone or cup. The shop has a compact interior, with additional seating available on the patio for enjoying dessert outdoors.

Mardi Gras Homemade Ice Cream is a small, family-run shop known for its housemade ice creams in both classic and internationally inspired flavors. Guests highlight distinctive options such as jasmine, rose, and traditional South Asian flavors alongside familiar favorites. The owners are often on hand, creating a welcoming atmosphere and sharing their passion for the craft.

Whit's Frozen Custard serves rich, creamy frozen custard with classic flavors like vanilla and chocolate alongside rotating flavors of the week. Guests can enjoy sundaes and specialty treats, with options that range from candy-inspired creations to fruit-forward desserts. Simple grilled items are also available for a quick bite. Take-home quarts and a drive-through window add convenience to this community-minded spot.

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams specializes in rich, flavorful ice creams with inventive combinations alongside classic favorites like darkest chocolate and honey vanilla bean. Small neighborhood shops and a sidewalk service window create an easygoing, walk-up experience. Guests often sample several flavors, with options like mini samplers adding a playful touch to the visit.

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams specializes in rich, creamy artisan ice creams made with high-quality ingredients and inventive flavor combinations. Signature options such as deeply chocolate varieties, fruit-and-cream blends, and salted peanut butter with chocolate pieces highlight the shop’s imaginative style. Friendly staff offer guidance on flavors and pairings, and some locations provide outdoor seating or a lively market setting.

Diamonds Ice Cream specializes in creamy ice cream and homemade paletas in a wide range of flavors, from classic to more adventurous options. Guests can choose between milk-based bars and lighter ice versions, with generous portions and fresh taste. The shop also offers Mexican street-style snacks with salty, tangy, sweet, and spicy notes. Attentive staff encourage sampling and help guide flavor choices.

Graeter’s Ice Cream is a local favorite known for rich, ultra-smooth ice cream and generous chocolate “chip” pieces, especially in its signature Black Raspberry Chip flavor. Guests appreciate the option to sample flavors, as well as classic milkshakes. The shop is kept very clean and offers a bright, family-friendly space with attentive, welcoming staff.