The Best American Restaurants in Johnstown, Ohio

Troyer’s Marketplace combines an Amish country store, deli, and café in a welcoming setting. Shelves feature a broad selection of spices, mixes, and seasonal local produce alongside baked goods such as breads, cookies, donuts, and pies. The deli is known for meats, cheeses, and made-to-order sandwiches, with indoor and outdoor seating available. Attentive, courteous service contributes to its inviting small-market feel.