The 20 Best American Restaurants in Troy, Ohio

The Caroline offers a classic American dining experience centered on steak and seafood, with dishes such as prime rib, halibut, and scallops prepared with care. Guests highlight attentive, observant service and well-timed courses. A varied beer and wine selection complements the meal, and rich desserts, including chocolate cake, provide a satisfying finish.

K's Hamburger Shop offers classic American diner fare in a nostalgic, old-school setting. Juicy cheeseburgers, homemade fries, chili, and crisp onion rings are staples, with malts and milkshakes frequently praised. The decor retains a vintage charm while remaining spotless, and the counter team provides straightforward, efficient service that suits the lively, community-oriented atmosphere.

Basil's on Market serves approachable American fare, from burgers and fries to wraps, salads, and shareable starters. Guests describe the food as flavorful and fresh, with crisp fries and ripe fruit among the highlights. Set in a nicely updated historic downtown building, the restaurant offers a comfortable atmosphere with generally friendly service.

Mojos Bar & Grille offers a casual bar-and-grill experience with a wide selection of brews and a well-stocked bar for cocktails. The menu features elevated pub favorites, including hearty burgers, sandwiches, flatbreads, and shareable appetizers like pretzels with beer cheese. This small venue has a youthful, energetic feel, and the attentive, welcoming staff contribute to its inviting atmosphere.

Outback Steakhouse offers classic American steakhouse fare, featuring grilled steaks, shrimp dishes, and fresh salads. Guests mention well-prepared meats, crisp salads, and warm bread. Service is attentive and efficient, contributing to a smooth dining experience. The restaurant suits both relaxed family meals and casual date nights.

Dunaway's Beef & Ale offers classic pub comfort food with a broad selection ranging from loaded pizzas and hearty sandwiches to roast beef, ribs, and chili. Guests highlight the fresh ingredients and consistently flavorful dishes, including popular appetizers like shrimp cocktail and cheese fries. The setting is relaxed and welcoming, with attentive service that adds to the laid-back neighborhood pub feel.

Applebee's offers familiar American bar-and-grill favorites, from steaks and shrimp to signature riblets. The menu evolves while keeping popular classics, and the house wines complement the food. Guests note attentive service that readily addresses any issues and a lively dining room with background country music.

Submarine House is a neighborhood sports bar known for hearty subs, pizzas, and other pub-style sandwiches, including vegetarian options. Guests highlight the flavorful Italian-style subs and housemade chips with dipping sauces. A solid selection of draft and bottled beers and personable bartenders contribute to its upbeat, social atmosphere.