The 20 Best Restaurants in Westerville

Set within a contemporary hotel, The Two-One Restaurant, Bar & Patio offers a bright, open setting with a bar, lounge, indoor dining, outdoor seating, and firepits. The menu features approachable American-style dishes such as steak, pasta, and shareable snacks, along with classic cocktails and wine. Modern décor, ambient colored lighting, and attentive, friendly service create an inviting spot for both hotel guests and locals.

Chicken Salad Chick specializes in a wide variety of chicken salad styles, known for consistent texture and fresh mix-ins like fruit and nuts. Guests appreciate the chance to sample flavors, along with comforting options such as chicken artichoke Florentine soup and sweet baked treats. Counter service is efficient, and staff are noted for being accommodating and helpful, including with catering orders.

Delaney's Diner offers classic American diner favorites, from hearty egg breakfasts and challah French toast to sandwiches with fries. Generous portions and consistently hot plates are a hallmark. The staff stays attentive and upbeat even when the room is busy, contributing to an energetic, old-fashioned diner atmosphere.

Polaris Grill offers contemporary American cuisine in a spacious dining room with inviting decor and soft jazz in the background. The menu features a range of options, from seafood such as salmon and walleye to flatbreads, sandwiches, soups, and salads. Portions are generous, and guests often note the well-prepared mushroom bisque. Attentive, efficient service and a clean, comfortable setting define the experience.

Antonio's is known for its thin-crust pizzas with a balanced layer of homemade sauce, cheese, and toppings. The menu extends to hearty Italian-American staples, including spaghetti with meatballs, substantial salads, wings, and subs. A make-your-own pizza option for children adds to the family-friendly appeal, and outdoor seating enhances the casual, neighborhood atmosphere.

Just Pies specializes in classic American pies, known for tender, flavorful crusts and generous fruit fillings. Guests highlight options like apple, peach, and seasonal flavors, along with no-sugar-added varieties that still deliver full flavor. Frequently chosen for holidays and gatherings, this bakery offers a welcoming, lighthearted atmosphere and a wide selection of sizes and fillings.

Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern offers a casual sports bar atmosphere with plenty of TVs, indoor seating, and a pet-friendly patio at the New Albany location. The menu focuses on American comfort food, including burgers, pizzas, and shareable snacks, with consistently well-prepared dishes. Attentive, generally friendly service and an energetic crowd make it a popular neighborhood gathering spot.

Asterisk Supper Club combines the feel of a cozy library, vintage bar, and intimate tea room in downtown Westerville. The space features book-lined menus, chandeliers, and a speakeasy-inspired bar serving creative cocktails. Guests enjoy classic supper club dishes alongside a popular afternoon tea service with tiered selections of scones, sandwiches, and sweets. Attentive, knowledgeable staff contribute to a relaxed, welcoming experience.

Zoup! specializes in a wide variety of soups, complemented by fresh salads and sandwiches. Guests can sample different options before choosing, with daily specials alongside popular favorites like chicken pot pie or lobster bisque. Each soup is served with a choice of bread, and the staff provide attentive, welcoming service. The relaxed setting and careful packaging make it convenient for both dine-in and takeout.

Northstar Café in Uptown Westerville offers a health-conscious, globally influenced menu alongside a few indulgent desserts. Guests order at the counter and have meals delivered to their table, creating an efficient yet relaxed experience. The inviting modern space suits both casual gatherings and quiet, solo visits, with friendly staff adding to the welcoming feel.

Java Central Café and Roaster is a character-filled coffeehouse set in a converted house, with multiple rooms, couches, and outdoor seating suited to both work and casual meetups. The café serves its own roasted coffee, including specialty drinks like a Buckeye and a Cubano-style espresso, alongside simple baked goods and quiche. Local artwork on the walls and occasional live music contribute to its laid-back, community-oriented feel.

Sunny Street Cafe offers classic American breakfast and lunch favorites in a bustling, welcoming setting. Diners praise the fresh-squeezed orange juice, hearty egg dishes, and comforting options like French toast, burgers, and wraps. Attentive staff and a consistently busy dining room contribute to its energetic atmosphere, with bar seating and outdoor tables available when the weather cooperates.

Giammarco's Italian Restaurant serves comforting Italian classics, from chicken parmesan and marsala to gnocchi and sausage with peppers, prepared with attention to flavor and temperature. Guests highlight the well-seasoned appetizers, including items like bruschetta, fried ravioli, and zucchini fries, as well as satisfying pizzas and salads. Attentive, personable service and a friendly, inviting dining room create an enjoyable experience for both small and larger groups.