The Best Pizza Restaurants in New Castle, Pennsylvania

Pizza Man's Pizza

3.56(0 reviews)

USD 15

Pizza / 9 S Jefferson St, New Castle, PA 16101, United States /

Classic Neighborhood Pizzeria

Pizza Man's Pizza is a straightforward neighborhood pizzeria known for its thick-crust pies loaded with cheese and flavorful sauce, as well as New York–style thin-crust and personal-size options. Guests note the homemade crust, balanced sauce, and well-prepared wings, along with daily specials and hearty soups. The no-frills setting includes pizza by the slice and a convenient pickup window, and the staff provides consistently friendly service.

Mangino's Pizzeria

3.40(0 reviews)

USD 15

Italian / 2710 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA 16105-1241, United States /

Casual Italian Pizzeria and Bakery

Mangino's Pizzeria offers classic Italian-American fare in a spacious, informal dining room. Guests highlight the pizza by the slice, hearty spinach rolls, stromboli, and sandwiches, along with comforting wedding soup. A selection of Italian cookies, cannoli, and biscotti rounds out the menu, and service is described as friendly and efficient.

Pizza Joe's

3.38(0 reviews)

USD 6

Pizza / 1203 N Croton Ave, New Castle, PA 16101, United States /

Mr Pizza

3.00(0 reviews)

USD 6

Pizza / 1204 E Washington St, New Castle, PA 16101, United States /

New York–Style Pizzeria with Casual Charm

Mr Pizza specializes in classic New York–style thin-crust pizza with a well-balanced sauce and generous cheese. Guests also mention hearty homemade soups, subs, and fresh salads. The setting is a straightforward pizza shop, noted for its cleanliness and efficient, personable service. A longstanding local spot, it offers a simple, satisfying slice experience.