The 20 Best Sandwich Restaurants in South Dakota

Firehouse Subs specializes in hot sandwiches prepared to order, with options ranging from classic combinations to richer fillings like beef brisket and cheese. Staff members are described as attentive and willing to customize orders to suit timing and preferences. The casual, family-friendly setting makes it convenient for a quick, satisfying meal.

Mr. Smith's Bakery Café & Catering is a distinctive Vermillion spot tucked inside a local hardware store, offering a casual, down-to-earth setting. The kitchen focuses on fresh, homemade fare, from hearty sandwiches and salads to fried chicken and pizzas. House-baked breads, especially the signature baguettes, are a highlight and are also available to take home.

Earl of Sandwich serves a variety of hot gourmet sandwiches, wraps, salads, and pizza bread in a casual, convenient setting. Guests highlight consistently flavorful, well-prepared sandwiches, including options like a Thanksgiving-inspired turkey creation. Efficient, organized service makes it a popular choice for both quick solo meals and larger group orders.

Pita Pit offers made-to-order pita sandwiches with a choice of white or wheat bread and a wide range of meats, falafel, fresh vegetables, cheeses, and sauces. Guests can select from suggested combinations or build their own. The counter-service setup emphasizes speed and convenience, with friendly staff and options suited to a quick, lighter meal.