The Best American Restaurants in Middlebury, Vermont

Jessica's at Swift House Inn

4.17(0 reviews)

USD 75

American / 25 Stewart Ln, Middlebury, VT 05753, United States /

Refined Contemporary American Dining

Jessica's Restaurant at the Swift House Inn offers refined contemporary American cuisine in an elegant inn setting. Diners highlight thoughtful preparations such as clam chowder, duck served two ways, expertly cooked steak, and rack of lamb, along with polished desserts like maple crème brûlée and sticky toffee pudding. Attentive service and a knowledgeable sommelier complement the carefully composed dishes and well-curated wine list.

Fire & Ice

3.79(0 reviews)

USD 22

Steakhouse / 26 Seymour St, Middlebury, VT 05753, United States /

Eclectic American Dining in a Collectors’ Setting

Fire & Ice offers an extensive American-style menu with dishes guests describe as flavorful and satisfying. The restaurant’s interior is highly distinctive, featuring a series of themed rooms filled with memorabilia, antiques, and curious details, along with patio seating and a lively bar. Attentive, friendly service and well-made cocktails contribute to an engaging dining experience.

Rosie's Restaurant

3.40(0 reviews)

USD 15

American / 886 US-7, Middlebury, VT 05753, United States /

Classic American Comfort Food in a Bustling Diner Setting

Rosie's Restaurant serves hearty American comfort food, from open-faced turkey sandwiches with mashed potatoes to fresh-baked pies. Seafood options such as clam strips are also popular with guests. The atmosphere is lively, often busy with locals and visitors, yet service remains attentive. Counter and bar seating add to the classic diner feel.

Waybury Inn

3.00(0 reviews)

USD 24

American / 457 E Main St, Middlebury, VT 05753, United States /

Historic New England Inn Dining

Waybury Inn offers classic New England pub and inn dining in a cozy, richly decorated historic setting. Guests praise hearty comfort dishes such as chowder, shepherd’s pie, burgers, and seafood specialties, along with fresh salads and soups. The inviting pub-style atmosphere and attentive, welcoming service create a relaxed, satisfying stop for travelers and locals alike.

Noonie's Deli

3.16(0 reviews)

USD 15

American / 137 Maple St, Middlebury, VT 05753, United States /

Hearty Sandwiches by the River

Noonie's Deli specializes in generously filled sandwiches, wraps, and salads made with notably fresh bread and high-quality ingredients. Guests highlight creative flavor combinations, from pesto chicken on ciabatta to seasonal specials and composed salads. Service is efficient and welcoming, with mainly takeout options plus limited indoor seating. Outdoor picnic tables offer a pleasant view of the nearby river and falls.

Morgan's Tavern at the Middlebury Inn

3.04(0 reviews)

USD 25

American / 14 Court Square, Middlebury, VT 05753, United States /

Vermont Coffee Company CAFE

3.00(0 reviews)

USD 6

American / 1197 Exchange St, Middlebury, VT 05753, United States /

Reservation Method

Distance

Price Range

Ratings

Seating Options

Hours

Smoking

Awards

Michelin Guide

Occasion

Facilities

Reservation Method

Distance

Price Range

Ratings

Seating Options

Hours

Smoking

Awards

Michelin Guide

Occasion

Facilities

Popular areas in Vermont

Trending Cuisines in Middlebury

The Best American Restaurants in Middlebury, Vermont

Burlington

Stowe

Rutland

Brattleboro

South Burlington

Essex Junction

Manchester

Bennington

Williston

Montpelier

Bar

American

Pizza

Contemporary

Italian

Tavern

International

Cafe

Pub

Indian

The Best Restaurants in Burlington, Vermont - American

The Best Restaurants in South Burlington - American