The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Vermont

The Parker Pie Company serves flavorful New York–style pizza with a crisp, well-developed crust and toppings ranging from classic margherita to hearty meat combinations. Guests can pair their meal with a selection of Vermont craft beer and cider, with several gluten-free options available. Both indoor seating and a relaxed outdoor area behind the restaurant offer comfortable places to linger.

American Flatbread specializes in wood-fired pizzas prepared in an open kitchen, where guests can watch the baking process in the glowing oven. The pizzas are noted for their fresh ingredients and balanced flavors. Attentive, friendly staff and a casual, bustling dining room create an inviting atmosphere for both small groups and larger gatherings.

Harry's Hardware combines a traditional hardware store with a cozy bar pouring a rotating selection of craft beers, local ciders, and wine. Guests can sip a drink while browsing the aisles and enjoying a casual, small menu on select days. Regular live music, including informal jam sessions, creates a lively community atmosphere.

Marigold Kitchen Pizza is a casual neighborhood spot known for its thoughtfully made pies and fresh salads. The kitchen emphasizes locally sourced Vermont ingredients, from the crust to the toppings, creating clean, well-balanced flavors. Gluten-free options and other dietary accommodations are available, and guests can enjoy their meal at the outdoor seating area.

Stone's Throw Pizza specializes in thoughtfully prepared pizzas, from classic Margherita to creative options like Buffalo chicken, all built on a well-regarded crust with gluten-free and dairy-free alternatives available. Fresh salads with distinctive dressings complement the menu, and a considered wine selection adds to the experience. The space is notably clean, the staff attentive, and guests can enjoy both the inviting dining room and the outdoor deck.

Poultney House of Pizza serves classic New York–inspired pies with well-balanced crust, sauce, cheese, and generous toppings. Guests praise the house special, Hawaiian combinations, and hearty heroes and calzones. Family photos on the walls highlight its long-standing legacy and add a personal touch to the welcoming setting.

Jimmz Pizza specializes in New York–style thin, crispy pizza with a well-regarded crust, complemented by pastas, soups, and sandwiches. An Italian sausage soup is frequently noted as a standout. Set in an old brick farmhouse, the space offers a simple, comfortable dining room where guests can watch their food being prepared. Clean surroundings and personable service complete the experience.

Pearl Street Pizza offers wood-fired pizzas, changing handmade pasta dishes, and generous salads in a lively, sunlit space shared with an Italian market. The kitchen highlights local ingredients, which come through in the flavors and overall quality. Guests can watch pizzas prepared in the open oven and choose from a concise selection of beer, wine, and cocktails. Attentive, down-to-earth service adds to the welcoming atmosphere.

Positive Pie Hardwick is a popular local spot known for consistently well-made, made-to-order pizzas, flavorful fries, and fresh salads. A full bar with cocktails and beer complements the food, and guests often enjoy watching a game while they dine. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, with friendly service that suits both visitors and regulars.

Pie In the Sky is a casual pizzeria and deli known for its spacious, comfortable dining room and welcoming service. The menu features sandwiches, pastas, and a variety of pizzas, including creative options like maple BBQ pulled pork alongside classic pepperoni. Pizzas are noted for their fresh toppings, balanced sauce and cheese, and appealing flavor combinations, with both dine-in and takeout experiences mentioned positively.

Cockadoodle Pizza Cafe offers a casual spot for pizza, paninis, and fresh salads in an older Main Street building with eclectic, retro-inspired decor. Guests order at the counter and have meals brought to their table, creating a laid-back, easygoing experience. Friendly staff and a relaxed playlist make it a comfortable place for lunch, dinner, or meeting with friends.

Piecasso is a welcoming pizzeria offering flavorful pies, subs, and fresh salads in a clean, lively setting. Guests note the tasty pizza by the slice and classic options like meatball subs and Caesar salad. Attentive, upbeat service and touches like trivia nights create a relaxed, enjoyable atmosphere for groups and solo diners alike.

Stone's Throw Pizza serves well-crafted pies featuring a chewy, crispy crust, with both classic combinations and options that showcase local ingredients. Fresh salads and a few housemade desserts round out the menu. The compact, open space is thoughtfully decorated with quirky details, while the bar offers local beers on tap and a small selection of wine. Friendly staff contribute to the inviting, neighborhood feel.

Hubbard Country Store combines the charm of a rural Vermont market with a welcoming café. Guests find house-made baked goods such as cupcakes, coffee cake, and brownies, along with sandwiches and pizzas prepared to order. The dark wood floors and open layout create an inviting setting, while the attentive staff emphasizes quality and personal service.

Hoagie's Pizza & Pasta is a casual spot known for its flavorful pizza with a well-liked crust, hearty subs, and a range of choices that appeal to all ages. The atmosphere is lively, especially on busy evenings, yet remains comfortable for groups. Counter ordering is complemented by attentive table service for larger parties, and staff are noted for being welcoming and efficient.

Ramunto's Brick & Brew Pizza offers a broad selection of pizzas with a choice of thin or thicker crusts, along with salads, sandwiches, and hearty starters. Guests highlight the generous portions, flavorful sauces, and well-made bar drinks. The lively, down-to-earth atmosphere and attentive staff create a relaxed, welcoming dining experience for locals and travelers alike.