The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Vermont

Harry's Hardware combines a traditional hardware store with a cozy bar pouring a rotating selection of craft beers, local ciders, and wine. Guests can sip a drink while browsing the aisles and enjoying a casual, small menu on select days. Regular live music, including informal jam sessions, creates a lively community atmosphere.

Marigold Kitchen Pizza is a casual neighborhood spot known for its thoughtfully made pies and fresh salads. The kitchen emphasizes locally sourced Vermont ingredients, from the crust to the toppings, creating clean, well-balanced flavors. Gluten-free options and other dietary accommodations are available, and guests can enjoy their meal at the outdoor seating area.

Stone's Throw Pizza specializes in thoughtfully prepared pizzas, from classic Margherita to creative options like Buffalo chicken, all built on a well-regarded crust with gluten-free and dairy-free alternatives available. Fresh salads with distinctive dressings complement the menu, and a considered wine selection adds to the experience. The space is notably clean, the staff attentive, and guests can enjoy both the inviting dining room and the outdoor deck.

Poultney House of Pizza serves classic New York–inspired pies with well-balanced crust, sauce, cheese, and generous toppings. Guests praise the house special, Hawaiian combinations, and hearty heroes and calzones. Family photos on the walls highlight its long-standing legacy and add a personal touch to the welcoming setting.

Jimmz Pizza specializes in New York–style thin, crispy pizza with a well-regarded crust, complemented by pastas, soups, and sandwiches. An Italian sausage soup is frequently noted as a standout. Set in an old brick farmhouse, the space offers a simple, comfortable dining room where guests can watch their food being prepared. Clean surroundings and personable service complete the experience.

Pie In the Sky is a casual pizzeria and deli known for its spacious, comfortable dining room and welcoming service. The menu features sandwiches, pastas, and a variety of pizzas, including creative options like maple BBQ pulled pork alongside classic pepperoni. Pizzas are noted for their fresh toppings, balanced sauce and cheese, and appealing flavor combinations, with both dine-in and takeout experiences mentioned positively.

Cockadoodle Pizza Cafe offers a casual spot for pizza, paninis, and fresh salads in an older Main Street building with eclectic, retro-inspired decor. Guests order at the counter and have meals brought to their table, creating a laid-back, easygoing experience. Friendly staff and a relaxed playlist make it a comfortable place for lunch, dinner, or meeting with friends.

Stone's Throw Pizza serves well-crafted pies featuring a chewy, crispy crust, with both classic combinations and options that showcase local ingredients. Fresh salads and a few housemade desserts round out the menu. The compact, open space is thoughtfully decorated with quirky details, while the bar offers local beers on tap and a small selection of wine. Friendly staff contribute to the inviting, neighborhood feel.

Pizza 44 serves carefully crafted pizzas with crisp yet tender crusts and flavorful sauces, complemented by local craft beer. Guests highlight creative topping combinations, including vegetarian options and specialty pies. Attentive staff, a clean, casual dining room, and active takeout service make it a popular neighborhood spot for families and groups.

Georgio's Pizza & Pasta serves classic, family-style pizza with a crisp crust, flavorful sauce, and fresh toppings. Guests describe the pizzas as reminiscent of traditional, old-school pizzerias. The staff is welcoming and efficient, handling both small parties and large groups with ease. A straightforward, satisfying spot for a relaxed pizza meal.

Pizza Man serves classic pizzas with a well-balanced crust, flavorful sauce, and generous toppings, including a gluten-free option that guests highlight for its texture and taste. The menu extends to hearty subs, pasta dishes with rich red sauce, and simple salads. A lively bar area and outdoor seating create a laid-back setting complemented by attentive, upbeat service.

Fire Tower Pizza serves thin, crisp, whole-grain crust pizzas topped with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Creative combinations, such as pies featuring cheddar, ham, apples, and maple syrup, highlight regional flavors. Located inside The Elmore Store by Lake Elmore, it offers an inviting setting with deck seating and views of the surrounding landscape.

Pizza Stone VT specializes in wood-fired pizza made with fresh ingredients, noted for flavorful sauce and basil. Guests appreciate the comfortable, spacious interior that contrasts with its modest exterior. Attentive staff and thoughtful touches for children, such as crayons and displayed artwork, create a welcoming, family-friendly setting. Salads and appetizers round out the casual dining experience.

Brattleboro Village Pizza serves classic pies with a focus on well-made dough, crisp crust, and generous toppings, including Italian-style sausage. The menu extends to hearty pasta dishes with meat sauce, melted cheese, and garlic bread, as well as fresh Greek salads. Guests note quick preparation, accommodating options, and a welcoming atmosphere.

Benner's Bagels Pizza N' What Nosh offers classic pizzeria favorites alongside Italian-style dinners and hearty grinders. Guests highlight the fresh, well-seasoned pizzas with crisp crusts, as well as dishes like chicken or eggplant Parmesan and steak and cheese sandwiches. Generous salads and a steady local crowd contribute to its easygoing, neighborhood feel.

Ramunto's Brick Oven Pizza serves New York–style pies with a focus on thin, flavorful crusts and generous toppings. Guests highlight specialty options such as ricotta-topped pizza and hearty steak sandwiches. The bustling open kitchen adds energy to the casual setting, where consistently made pizza is a central draw.