The Best Restaurants in Poultney

Poultney House of Pizza serves classic New York–inspired pies with well-balanced crust, sauce, cheese, and generous toppings. Guests praise the house special, Hawaiian combinations, and hearty heroes and calzones. Family photos on the walls highlight its long-standing legacy and add a personal touch to the welcoming setting.

Poultney Pub offers hearty tavern fare in a relaxed, welcoming setting. Guests highlight flavorful pulled pork sandwiches with tangy barbecue accents, crisp chicken tenders, and shareable plates like nachos. The bar features a selection of local beers and creative cocktails, including fresh, spicy options. Occasional live music and open-mic events add to the lively pub atmosphere.

The Cluckin Cafe & Cones Point Country Store combines a nostalgic country store setting with a café serving cooked-to-order comfort food near Lake St. Catherine. Guests find hearty breakfast sandwiches, classic deli favorites, and rotating weekend dinner specials prepared by an in-house chef. House coffee and a popular ice cream selection, including maple creemees, round out the casual, satisfying experience.