The Best Restaurants in Reedville

Cockrells Creek Seafood & Deli offers straightforward, coastal-style seafood in a casual, unfussy setting. Guests order at the counter and dine indoors or outside on picnic tables overlooking the water. Lightly breaded soft shell crab, crab cakes, and fried oysters are prepared to highlight their fresh, delicate flavor, complemented by classic sides like fries, coleslaw, and hushpuppies.

The Crazy Crab offers a relaxed setting for classic seafood and American comfort dishes. Diners highlight well-prepared crab, clams, and other seafood, along with satisfying non-seafood options like burgers and pork chops. Friendly, efficient service and the option to dine outdoors contribute to an enjoyable, easygoing experience.

Reedville Market offers American cuisine with a focus on regional seafood, including dishes such as Chesapeake-style crab cakes, grilled salmon, and fried shrimp. Guests dine in a renovated, spacious setting with notable harbor views from the dining room and deck. Professional, attentive service and house-made desserts, such as rich cakes and classic pies, round out the experience.

Fairport Marina offers a casual, unpretentious setting where classic comfort food meets fried seafood favorites. Guests highlight freshly cooked, homemade dishes and generous fish sandwiches, including a popular cod BLT. A cozy porch and outdoor seating complement the lively, often bustling dining room, while attentive, welcoming service adds to the relaxed local feel.