The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Richmond, Virginia

Bottoms Up Pizza offers creative, generously sized pies and slices with a variety of toppings, along with fresh salads and housemade dressings. The multi-level space features both indoor seating and a spacious outdoor patio. Guests highlight the welcoming, well-kept interior and attentive service, making it a comfortable stop in the Shockoe Bottom area.

Pupatella serves Neapolitan-style pizza baked in a wood-fired oven, featuring a soft, airy crust and simple, flavorful tomato sauce. Fresh toppings such as buffalo mozzarella and creamy burrata are highlighted across both red and white pizza options, including a build-your-own selection. The casual neighborhood setting and selection of wine and craft beer create an easygoing spot for relaxed dining.

Mellow Mushroom Richmond - Carytown serves inventive stone-baked pizzas, shareable appetizers, and fresh salads in a laid-back setting. Guests highlight flavorful specialty pies like shiitake and loaded potato varieties, along with satisfying dips and bruschetta. Fast, attentive service and a selection of casual drinks contribute to an easygoing dining experience.

Mary Angela's Pizzeria is a Carytown favorite for oven-baked pizza with a flavorful sauce, generous toppings, and a well-regarded crust. The menu extends to hearty Italian staples such as spaghetti with marinara, eggplant parmigiana, and substantial subs on homemade rolls. Friendly, attentive service and prompt pacing contribute to a comfortable, inviting dining experience.

Belmont Pizzeria serves classic Italian-American fare in Richmond’s Museum District, with thin-crust and Sicilian-style pizzas that draw consistent praise for their flavor. Guests highlight the well-executed margherita and creative specialty combinations. A broad menu of calzones, pastas, sandwiches, and familiar appetizers rounds out this casual local spot.

Piccola Italy Pizza & Subs offers a broad Italian-American menu, from pizzas and salads to pasta dishes and classic appetizers. Guests consistently note the flavorful pizzas, particularly the well-made crust. Service is attentive and personable, creating a welcoming experience in a modest, no-frills setting.

SuperstarsPizza & Subs specializes in take-and-bake pizzas complemented by a selection of subs and cookies. Guests highlight the convenience of baking the pizzas at home while still enjoying a fresh, pizzeria-style crust. The modest, neighborhood setting and attentive service create a straightforward, welcoming stop for casual, comforting fare.

Mike's Pizza & Grill serves generous portions of classic American-Italian comfort food, from jumbo pizzas to substantial subs and appetizers. Guests highlight the flavorful pies, filling sandwiches, and varied appetizer platters. Quick, courteous service and a straightforward, casual setting make it a reliable spot for a satisfying meal.

Christian's Pizza specializes in large 18-inch pies and generous slices displayed at the counter, featuring a wide range of topping combinations. Guests appreciate the flavorful crust and options like classic cheese, pepperoni, and margherita. The casual, no-frills setting suits both quick slices and takeout orders, with delivery and beer available for those dining in.

Ironclad Sports Bar offers classic pub fare with a focus on pizzas, wings, and other comfort dishes. Guests mention crisp crusts, generous toppings, and well-prepared bar snacks. Numerous TVs, a sizable bar, and outdoor seating with a play area create an easygoing sports bar environment. Service is described as friendly and efficient, even during quick meals.

Angela's Ristorante & Pizzeria serves traditional Italian dishes and pizzas in a welcoming, family-friendly setting. Guests highlight flavorful preparations, from veal and seafood specialties to eggplant parmigiana and housemade desserts. Attentive, knowledgeable service and a well-kept, comfortable dining room contribute to an enjoyable experience for both small and large groups.

California Pizza Kitchen at Short Pump serves a wide range of pizzas, pastas, soups, and salads in a casual, family-friendly setting. Guests highlight the flavorful pizzas, including options like cauliflower crust, as well as comforting dishes such as spaghetti Bolognese and hot bread. Fresh, generously composed salads and attentive, accommodating service contribute to a consistently satisfying dining experience.

Jo Jo's Pizza serves classic New York–style slices in a straightforward, bustling setting popular at lunchtime. Thin-crust pies with a variety of toppings, including a noted buffalo chicken option, are prepared quickly and served hot. Guests describe the staff as welcoming and attentive, contributing to an easygoing, neighborhood pizzeria feel.