The 20 Best Restaurants in Columbus, Wisconsin

Yumyum Thai Kitchen serves authentic Thai cooking with dishes like pad see eaw, fragrant curries, and noodle soups, prepared with customizable levels of heat. Diners highlight the extensive menu, including regional specialties and a Thai coffee and tea selection with traditional desserts. The restaurant offers a friendly atmosphere with plenty of natural light and a patio with a fire pit for outdoor dining in warm weather.

Club 60 offers classic American fare in a spacious dining room with a lively, social atmosphere. Guests highlight well-prepared dishes, from items like coconut shrimp to a generous soup and salad bar. Skilled bartenders mix polished cocktails, while attentive, knowledgeable staff contribute to a smooth and welcoming experience.

Apple Tree Family Restaurant offers classic American comfort food in a clean, well-lit dining room with ample space between tables. Generous portions of hearty breakfasts, such as skillets and pancakes, are a highlight, alongside familiar favorites like burgers, pasta, and ice cream desserts. Friendly, attentive service and a relaxed, family-oriented atmosphere define the experience.

Cercis Brewing Company offers a broad selection of house beers alongside hearty pub-style dishes in a welcoming, contemporary space. Guests highlight the Reuben, hot sandwiches, and generous salads, as well as the extensive beer list featuring styles such as IPAs and red ales. Regular events like trivia nights and book gatherings contribute to its lively, community-oriented atmosphere, supported by attentive, well-informed staff.

The Old Rock is a longstanding bar and grill known for hearty burgers, sandwiches, and classic fish plates served hot and well-prepared. Guests are welcomed promptly, with attentive staff in both the dining room and bar. TVs, live music, and a busy bar create an energetic yet laid-back spot for watching games or unwinding.

Mullin's Short Stop is a classic drive-in offering hearty burgers, fries with toppings, and creamy root beer floats. Guests enjoy carhop service or outdoor picnic-style seating in a bright, refreshed setting that keeps its nostalgic charm. Generous ice cream cones and a well-liked chicken sandwich round out the casual, family-friendly experience.

Columbus Family Restaurant is a well-kept, family-run spot offering hearty American comfort food with a noticeable Mexican influence. Guests appreciate the all-day breakfast, from classic plates to Mexican-style omelets, along with a wide range of casual favorites and desserts. Portions are generous, and the welcoming staff creates a relaxed, neighborly atmosphere.

Culver's offers classic Midwestern fast-casual fare, with signature Butterburgers, fish plates, and smooth frozen custard as the main draw. Guests note consistently well-prepared food and an efficient, courteous team. Management is attentive in resolving any issues, creating a dependable and welcoming stop for a satisfying meal.