20 restaurantes Pizza por Recomendación en Pickerington

Pizza Cottage is a casual spot known for its flavorful pizzas and hearty Italian-American favorites such as spaghetti and meatballs. Guests mention tender meatballs, a mildly sweet sauce, and fresh salads. The restaurant offers table service, a dedicated party room for groups, and a drive-thru window that makes takeout pickup convenient.

Donatos Pizza is a locally founded chain known for its consistently hot, fresh pizzas with generous toppings, including its signature edge-to-edge pepperoni. The menu also features subs, calzones, wings, and salads for a casual, family-friendly meal. Guests highlight reliable delivery and smooth carry-out service, with attentive, professional staff enhancing the overall experience.

Pizzeria New York specializes in classic New York–style pies with a thin, foldable crust that is crispy on the edges and chewy throughout. Guests highlight the flavorful homemade sauce, generous cheese, and traditional pie-cut slices. The menu also includes strombolis and subs. A compact dining room with beer service and televisions for sports creates an easygoing neighborhood feel, supported by attentive staff.

Romeo's Pizza serves classic and specialty pies with a choice of thin, traditional, or Sicilian-style crust and a notably sweet tomato sauce. Popular options include a Margherita-style pizza and hearty pepperoni and Greek-inspired combinations, complemented by subs and cheesy garlic bread. The casual dining room, carryout, and delivery options make it a convenient spot for enjoying familiar pizzeria favorites.