20 ausgewählte Italian Restaurants in Old Lyme nach Empfehlung

Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace is a casual pizzeria with a diner-style feel, decorated with soccer memorabilia and offering both dine-in and takeout. The kitchen specializes in thin-crust pizzas with a distinctive, soft texture and a variety of toppings, alongside hearty grinders and fresh salads. Attentive service and a laid-back atmosphere make it a comfortable spot for a relaxed meal with beer or soft drinks.

Pizza Plus is a casual neighborhood spot known for its classic pizzas with crispy crusts and generous toppings. Guests also appreciate the grinders, wings, antipasto salad, and notably crisp french fries. The modest, no-frills space leans toward takeout, with efficient service and the option to call ahead for orders.

Pizzeria Da Vinci is a local take-out spot known for its thin-crust pizzas with balanced toppings and a well-made crust. The menu also includes salads, grinders, wings, and mozzarella sticks that are described as consistently tasty. A steady stream of regulars and welcoming staff contribute to its down-to-earth, neighborhood feel.