20 ausgewählte Italian Restaurants in Columbus nach Empfehlung

Z Cucina di Spirito offers contemporary Italian cuisine in an inviting, well-appointed setting. Guests highlight the housemade pastas, vibrant salads, and distinctive bread served with a sun-dried tomato and olive oil dip. Thoughtfully prepared desserts such as tiramisu and gelato round out the experience. Attentive, knowledgeable service complements the polished yet comfortable atmosphere.

Marcella’s offers classic Italian comfort food in a lively, social setting that suits both small gatherings and larger groups. Guests highlight flavorful pastas, generous meatballs, crisp pizzas, and well-prepared appetizers. Attentive, personable service and the ability to accommodate gluten-free diets contribute to a consistently enjoyable dining experience.

Martini Modern Italian offers contemporary Italian cuisine with well-executed pastas, hearty meat dishes, and popular starters like housemade mozzarella. Guests highlight flavorful desserts, including a rich chocolate bread pudding, alongside classic cocktails and a thoughtful wine list. The atmosphere is bustling yet comfortable, and the attentive, knowledgeable staff help create a polished but approachable dining experience, even for larger groups.

The Rossi Kitchen & Bar offers a stylish, softly lit setting for Italian-inspired comfort food, burgers, and pizzas. Guests praise the flavorful house pasta, crisp salads, and a standout Nashville chicken sandwich. A well-made cocktail and wine selection complements the menu, while attentive service helps create an inviting experience.

Trattoria Roma offers classic Italian cooking with hearty pasta dishes, chicken specialties, and freshly baked bread with garlic butter. The menu includes satisfying vegetarian options, such as polenta and vegetable lasagna with richly flavored sauces. Indoor and outdoor seating create a comfortable setting, while attentive, knowledgeable service supports an enjoyable dining experience.

Carrabba's Italian Grill offers a mix of Italian favorites and grilled specialties, from chicken and eggplant dishes to well-prepared seafood. Sauces are flavorful, sides like asparagus, spinach, and mashed potatoes are carefully seasoned, and warm bread with olive oil sets the tone. Guests describe attentive service, prompt seating, and special wine dinners guided by knowledgeable staff.

Nicola Restaurant & Bar offers classic Italian cuisine in a welcoming setting with a charming flower-lined patio. Guests highlight well-executed dishes such as Caprese salad and arancini, complemented by a thoughtful wine list and housemade limoncello. Attentive, efficient service and a comfortable outdoor area with heaters contribute to a relaxed, enjoyable dining experience.

Das Villa Nova Ristorante bietet unkomplizierte italienische Komfortküche, von Pizza und Sandwiches im mittleren Westen bis hin zu vertrauten Pasta-Gerichten. Glutenfreie Pizza-Optionen und klassische Desserts wie Schokoladenkuchen und Cannoli erhöhen die Attraktivität. Die Atmosphäre ist lässig und unprätentiös, mit einer lebhaften Menge und einem aktiven Barbereich.

BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse offers a broad American menu in a casual brewhouse setting, with generous portions of comfort dishes such as slow-roasted tri tip and parmesan-crusted chicken. Sides like white cheddar mashed potatoes and fresh salads are noted for their flavor. The bar serves a range of well-crafted drinks, including popular sangria-style cocktails, and staff make an effort to accommodate guests, whether at tables or the bar.

Carfagna's Kitchen combines a full-service Italian restaurant, lively bar, wine shop, and specialty market in one expansive space. Guests find classic Italian comfort dishes such as thin-crust pizza and arancini alongside housemade sausages and baked goods. The setting evokes a small Italian marketplace, with a warm, inviting atmosphere and plenty to explore before or after a meal.

Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant serves classic Italian‑American dishes in a bustling, convivial setting. Guests highlight flavorful pastas and sharable favorites like manicotti and mozzarella bread. The spacious dining areas and energetic atmosphere make it a popular choice for groups and special celebrations, with staff who strive to accommodate large parties and busy evenings.

Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza serves classic Italian-American comfort food, including stromboli, pizza, fries, pasta, and hearty sandwiches. Guests highlight the light, flavorful dough and balanced red sauce. The restaurant offers accommodations for those avoiding meat or dairy. A recent remodel gives the space a refreshed, easygoing feel with convenient parking nearby.

Smith's Restaurant and Deli offers a straightforward, classic deli experience with a focus on sandwiches, pizza, and fresh salads. Guests mention well-prepared subs such as meatball and chicken parmesan, along with traditional favorites like a simple BLT. The setting is unpretentious, with basic tables, historic photos, and the aroma of pizzas from the oven, creating a quiet spot for a relaxed meal. Homemade-style cookies and a selection of beverages round out the casual menu.

Bravo! Italian Kitchen offers classic Italian‑American comfort food in a relaxed, welcoming setting. Guests highlight generous pastas such as shrimp and lobster fettuccine, veal dishes, and fresh salads, along with warm focaccia and dipping oil. Cheesecake and tiramisu provide a satisfying finish, while attentive service contributes to an easygoing dining experience.

Brio Italian Grille serves familiar Italian fare in a comfortable, sit-down setting suitable for both everyday meals and special occasions. Guests highlight well-prepared entrées and enjoyable appetizers. Service is generally attentive and efficient, with staff working to accommodate both small and larger groups. The overall experience combines satisfying food with a casual, welcoming atmosphere.

Bravo! Italian Kitchen offers classic Italian dishes, from chicken and eggplant parmigiana to salmon and popular shrimp appetizers. Fresh salads, warm soups, and house bread complement the main courses, with portions described as satisfying. Service is attentive and knowledgeable about the menu and wine selection, creating a pleasant, relaxed dining experience.

Tony's Italian Ristorante serves classic Italian favorites in a traditional, welcoming setting. Guests highlight hearty pastas, seafood dishes, and house specialties such as lasagna, wedding soup, and arancini. Fresh bread with garlic butter and well-prepared seafood and veal dishes add to the appeal. Attentive staff and a convivial bar contribute to the overall experience.