20 ausgewählte Pizza Restaurants in Columbus nach Empfehlung

Terita’s Pizza is a carryout-only, mom-and-pop style pizzeria known for its thin, flavorful crust and generous toppings. The house-made sausage, cooked directly on the pizza, and zesty pepperoni are frequent favorites. Pies are prepared to order and maintain a consistent, traditional flavor that keeps guests returning.

Dewey’s Pizza offers a lively, family-friendly setting with an open kitchen where guests can watch pizzas being prepared. The menu centers on hand-tossed pizzas with creative topping combinations, along with generous calzones and fresh seasonal salads. Guests appreciate the option to mix flavors on half-and-half pizzas and the accommodating, attentive service.

Dewey's Pizza offers handcrafted pizzas with inventive flavor combinations, including options for vegan and gluten-free diners. Specialty pies and rotating seasonal creations feature thoughtful toppings and well-balanced flavors, complemented by fresh salads. Attentive, knowledgeable staff help guide guests through the menu in a lively, well-run dining room.

Pies & Pints - Columbus, OH specializes in flavorful, stone-baked pizzas paired with a broad selection of beers. Guests highlight the crisp yet tender crust, well-seasoned sauce, and creative options, including vegetarian-friendly pies and fresh salads. The house salad and specialty pizzas receive frequent praise. Attentive, personable service and a relaxed atmosphere round out the experience, whether dining in or ordering delivery.

Figlio is a long-standing neighborhood restaurant, open since 1991, known for its welcoming atmosphere and consistently well-prepared food. The lively bar and expanded dining areas create an energetic setting that stays busy throughout the evening. A private dining room accommodates special gatherings, with attentive staff coordinating details from appetizers to celebratory toasts. Dishes such as the popular drunken shrimp highlight the kitchen’s approachable, flavorful style.

Dante's Pizza serves classic, old-school pies known for a perfectly baked crust that is both chewy and crisp. Housemade sausage with a distinct caraway flavor is a standout topping, complemented by a simple, satisfying sauce and melted cheese. The restaurant offers the option to purchase pizza dough for home baking and provides attentive, welcoming service in a traditional pizzeria setting.

Emelio's Restaurant is a small, old-school pizzeria with a lively bar and both covered and open patio seating. The kitchen focuses on crispy, well-cooked pizzas, especially popular with pepperoni and mushrooms, alongside a signature salad generously topped with meats and cheese. Guests describe a straightforward setting where the emphasis is firmly on hearty flavors and a sociable, familiar crowd.

Adriatico's New York Style Pizza serves generous, hand-tossed pies known for a flavorful, sauce-forward style. The menu also includes wings, appetizers, salads, and draft beer. A cozy dining room with Ohio State memorabilia, TVs showing sports, and a small outdoor seating area creates a casual, campus-oriented atmosphere. Delivery is available for those who prefer to enjoy the pizza at home.

Harvest Bar + Kitchen - Clintonville offers a casual neighborhood setting for creative American comfort food, including pizzas, burgers, and shareable small plates. Guests highlight the quality of the gluten-free options, housemade desserts, and inventive cocktails, along with attentive, personable service.

Yogi's Hoagies & Dairy Bar is a casual neighborhood spot known for its freshly made hoagies and subs, offered hot or cold, with options including vegetarian fillings. Guests also mention enjoying the French bread pizza. The setting is relaxed and unpretentious, with nostalgic memorabilia adding character and making it a long-standing favorite in the area.

Rubinos Pizza is a long-standing, family-run pizzeria known for its distinctive thin, cracker-crust pies. House-made ingredients and a crisp, light base define the signature style. The simple, retro dining room reflects decades of neighborhood history, drawing a loyal following that appreciates its consistent, traditional approach to pizza.

Slammers is a welcoming bar and pizza venue known for its flavorful, customizable pies, including a popular Sicilian-style option. Guests highlight the crisp crust, generous toppings, and consistently hot, fresh pizzas. The atmosphere is inclusive and energetic, drawing a diverse crowd from the local community. A spacious patio and attentive bar service complete the casual, social setting.

Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus offers fast-casual dining focused on freshly made pizzas and customizable salads. Guests order at the counter and then relax while staff bring food to the table. Pizzas are noted for their hot, crisp finish and high-quality ingredients that highlight individual flavors. The compact dining area suits both quick meals and small groups.

Hounddog's Pizza offers hearty, customizable pizzas with options such as thin or hand-tossed crust and a flavorful house sauce. The dining room features rock music, wooden tables, dim red lighting, and nostalgic artwork, anchored by a long central bar. Relaxed, attentive service and plenty of seating make it comfortable for both small groups and larger gatherings, with a selection of beers available on tap.

Iacono's Pizza & Restaurant serves classic Italian-American comfort food, including crisp, generously topped pizzas, hearty lasagna dinners, and substantial Italian subs on fresh, crusty bread. A simple salad bar and composed side salads round out the meal. Consistent flavors and satisfying portions make this a familiar spot for relaxed, casual dining.

Donatos Pizza is a longstanding local chain known for its thin, crispy crust and generously topped pies. Guests highlight well-cooked personal and large pizzas, including classic pepperoni and simple options like margherita, along with fresh salads. The atmosphere is casual and relaxed, with counter service that is described as efficient, attentive, and welcoming.